Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - US
The Guardian - US
Comment
Arwa Mahdawi

Little Mermaid’s racist critics pollute magical undersea world with bigotry

Halle Bailey as the Little Mermaid.
Halle Bailey as the Little Mermaid. Photograph: Disney

More proof that racism rots your brain

Grown men are getting triggered by a little mermaid. Disney recently released a trailer for a new live-action version of the Little Mermaid starring Halle Bailey, a Black actor, and it has sparked a depressingly predictable racist backlash. The trailer has received 1.5m dislikes on YouTube and caused a lot of bigots to have a conniption fit. If you’re getting a sense of deja vu about all this, it’s because the same people already had a meltdown in 2019, when the live-action remake was first announced.

It’s not just the Little Mermaid: rightwingers, the people who love telling liberals to toughen up snowflake, routinely get their knickers in a twist over animated entertainment targeted at the four-to-12-year-old crowd. There seems to be a backlash about diversity onscreen every five minutes. Earlier this month, for example, the right were getting het up over a lesbian polar bear family in Peppa Pig. I don’t know how they have the energy to care about cartoon polar bears; it really must be very exhausting.

While there may be nothing new about bigots raging over animated entertainment, this particular backlash is noteworthy because of just how unhinged the response has been. An anonymous computer scientist, for example, went to the trouble of using artificial intelligence to whiten Halle Bailey’s appearance in the trailer. A (now-suspended) Twitter account jubilantly shared the altered trailer, announcing: “Credits to our memer Artificial intelligence scientist. He fixed The Little Mermaid and turned the woke actor into a ginger white girl.” Shortly after the Twitter account added: “This is purely for educational purposes, please do not misinterpret this in a racist way.” Uh huh.

Conservative political commentator Matt Walsh also spent a lot more time thinking about the physiology of fictional creatures than is healthy. Walsh told viewers of his eponymous show that “from a scientific perspective, it doesn’t make a lot of sense to have someone with darker skin who lives deep in the ocean. If anything, not only should the Little Mermaid be pale, she should, actually, be translucent. If you look at deep-sea creatures, they’re translucent. They have no kind of pigmentation whatsoever … [The Little Mermaid] should be totally pale and skeletal where you can see her skull through her face.”

Walsh later said what all racists say when people call them out: his statement about a Black mermaid being unscientific was a joke! Which would have been a lot more convincing of an argument if Walsh hadn’t built his brand on far-right views.

Walsh clearly has an active imagination so I’d like to suggest a little thought experiment to him: try imagining a world where you grew up rarely seeing someone like yourself be a hero onscreen. Walsh is an able-bodied thirtysomething white guy. He grew up with no end of TV shows and movies starring boys who looked like him. If you take that representation for granted then it can be hard to understand how important it is to see yourself included in popular culture. It can be hard to understand how dehumanizing it is to be constantly sent the message that people who look like you can never be heroes. I’m speaking from personal experience here: the other day I found myself unexpectedly shedding a tear because Mo Amer was on The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon talking about how his new Netflix show, Mo, is “the first ever show created by, starring a Palestinian, and showing a Palestinian family on television”. As a Palestinian, I wish there had been something like Mo on TV when I was growing up.

The nine millionth remake of the Little Mermaid may not be something that you personally care about, but do try and imagine how important it is for a little girl to see someone who looks like her playing a heroine onscreen. There’s a very wholesome TikTok trend of Black girls watching the Little Mermaid trailer and being delighted that “she’s like me! She’s like me!” If your reaction to little girls feeling included is to dismiss is it as “woke”, then there is something deeply wrong with you. Not only are you a bad human, you’re also a bad capitalist. The US is growing increasingly diverse, whether people like Walsh like it or not. In 2019 non-whites and Hispanics constituted a majority of people under age 16 for the first time. Forgive my cynicism, but I don’t think Disney isn’t trying to be “woke” with the Little Mermaid. It is simply responding to good old-fashioned market forces.

PMS is a ‘key public health issue globally’, new study finds

Researchers surveyed 238,000 people across 140 countries about the effects of premenstrual syndrome (PMS). They found (unsurprisingly!) that PMS is incredibly common and “a majority of women reported that their premenstrual symptoms interfered with their everyday life at least some of the time”.

How have history and science shaped the gendering of our emotions?

This week I spoke to Pragya Agarwal about her new book, Hysterical, which examines how we gender emotions. You can watch the event, hosted by the RSA, for free here.

A growing number of men are undergoing painful leg lengthening surgery

It costs $75,000 for the procedure which adds between three to six inches to your height, and involves getting both your femurs broken. One man interviewed by GQ said he’s keeping the surgery a secret and is going to tell everyone that his extra inches are a side-effect of the Covid vaccine. While that’s hilarious, the story itself is a sad reminder that gendered expectations negatively affect men just as much as women.

Appeal raises $150,000 for girl ordered to pay family of accused rapist she killed

A tiny bit of good news in a story that will make your blood boil.

Pakistan’s floods put pregnant women in danger

A third of the country is under water and almost 650,000 women in affected areas need maternity services.

Beige flags: the warning signs that announce you’re too boring to date

Having strong opinions about whether pineapple belongs on a pizza is apparently one of them.

The week in pawntriarchy

A few weeks ago a Reddit user with a very overactive imagination came up with a wild theory that a chess champion had been using vibrating anal beads that indicated the best moves. This theory somehow took on a life of its own and become a huge scandal in the chess world. Now a popular cam site is offering $1m to Grandmaster Hans Niemann to broadcast himself playing a live game of chess naked to disprove the accusations. Your move, Niemann.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.