Though veterans Marcus Stroman and Drew Smyly have boosted the Cubs’ pitching rotation, it’s 27-year-old left-hander Justin Steele who better represents the hopes of a Cubs rebirth — a homegrown starter, drafted and developed by the organization who has reached another level in each of his three seasons in the big leagues.
But it wasn’t his day Friday.
Steele, who came into the game against the Reds with a 6-1 record, a 2.20 ERA and 8-of-10 quality starts, was hit hard early and often in a 9-0 loss before 31,946 fans at Wrigley Field. He allowed 10 hits and six runs in 3 2/3 innings. One of the runs was unearned, but only because of Steele’s own error, when he dropped a throw from first baseman Matt Mervis on Curt Casali’s sacrifice bunt. It was that kind of day for Steele — and the Cubs, who were shut out for the first time this season.
“It didn’t feel like his day today,” Cubs manager David Ross said. “I don’t know that I ever felt [the Reds] took any bad swings. Their swings were pretty aggressive, even the ones they fouled off or swung and missed. When they’re like that, you’ve got to get under the barrel. The slider is usually the one. For him, it just didn’t look sharp to me. You’re going to have days like that — he’s been so good for us.”
Steele (6-2) allowed several sharply hit balls — including Spencer Steer’s RBI triple in the first (104.8 mph exit velocity), Steer’s single in the fourth (101.3) and Kevin Newman’s double in the fourth (103.6) and saw his ERA rise to 2.77. But he wasn’t buying the notion that he just didn’t have it.
“I wouldn’t say that,” Steele said. “In the bullpen leading into the game, and even throughout the game, I felt like I had my stuff. I felt like I was executing pitches — similar to outings prior to this. I felt like I was commanding my four-seamer and making pitches and the other team [the Reds] was doing a good job of battling stuff off — the swing-and-miss pitches, fouling them off. Just give credit to the other team for doing what they were supposed to do.”
It was a day of mystifying performances in which the Cubs ended up being outhit 19-2 and were six outs from being no-hit. With Steele falling behind 2-0 in the first inning, 3-0 in the third and 6-0 in the fourth, the Cubs’ offense withered against Reds starter Hunter Greene.
The No. 2 overall pick in the 2017 draft, Greene came in with an 0-4 record and 4.68 ERA. He had allowed 26 hits and 17 runs in 22 innings (6.95 ERA) over his previous four starts. But he held the Cubs hitless for six innings.
Greene struck out 11 batters, including Dansby Swanson twice. He was pulled after throwing 110 pitches through six innings. Reliever Eduardo Salazar retired the Cubs 1-2-3 in the seventh inning. But Christopher Morel singled sharply to center to break up the no-hitter. Miles Mastrobuoni singled one batter later for the Cubs other hit. Only two other Cubs batters reached base — Mike Tauchman walked with two outs in the second. Ian Happ walked with two outs in the fourth.
“We got to some really deep counts consistently [against Greene] and then he just blew some doors — that fastball riding 99 up was tough to get on top of,” Ross said. “Guys worked the count pretty well early on. [We] just weren’t able to capitalize and win the at-bat.”
