Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Zenger
Zenger
World
Alberto Arellano

Jewish Student Claims Victory Against University Of Leeds

Leeds University Main Building in Leeds city center. Leeds is the largest city in the northern English county of Yorkshire. The school agreed to pay the sociology graduate an undisclosed sum after graders failed her essay for being insufficiently anti-Israel. RAHMAN HASSANI/JNS

The University of Leeds settled a legal claim brought by sociology graduate Danielle Greyman after her coursework was wrongly failed because it did not blame Israel for the crimes of Hamas against Palestinians. 

The university agreed to pay Greyman an undisclosed sum. 

Roger Stevens Building, Chancellor’s Square, Leeds University, West Yorkshire, 2012. Detail view of the west elevation of the building, designed by Chamberlin, Powell and Bon and completed in 1970. Greyman’s examiners failed her for not discussing supposed crimes committed by Israel and because the essay was too short. ENGLISH HERITAGE/JNS

Greyman was assisted by UK Lawyers for Israel (UKLFI) Charitable Trust in her appeal and legal claim, in which she was represented by Jonathan D.C. Turner, barrister, and Daniel Berke, solicitor, both directors of UK Lawyers for Israel. 

“We are very pleased with the settlement and hope that it will serve as a warning to universities and academics not to allow marking to be influenced by the anti-Israel bias which is so prevalent in academia. Ms. Greyman is to be congratulated for standing up to this dogma,” Turner said in a statement put out by UKLFI. 

Greyman chose “State crime and immorality” as an optional module in the final year of her three-year B.A. course in sociology in the 2020/2021 academic year. 

With her tutors’ agreement, Greyman decided to write about the crimes committed against Palestinians by Hamas, and the U.N.’s contribution to these crimes. 

Her examiners failed her for not discussing supposed crimes committed by Israel and because the essay was too short (even though it met the specified requirement of 5,000 words +/- 10%). 

“The feedback on the essay by the markers also indicated hostility and prejudice against Israel, as did their social media,” the UKLFI statement said. 

Students take part in a protest in Leeds city centre, to support university workers as they begin a month of walkouts in the latest stage of a bitter dispute over pensions. Danielle Greyman chose “State crime and immorality” as an optional module in the final year of her three-year B.A. course in sociology. DANNY LAWSON/JNS

Greyman had never failed an assignment before and was on track to receive a class 2.1 Honours Degree. 

Her coursework had earlier been revised to a passing grade following Greyman’s successful internal appeal, and she has been awarded a B.A. degree with Honours in Class 2.1. 

However, the appeal process and regrading took more than a year, and the university’s confirmation of Greyman’s entitlement to the degree came too late to enable her to take up a place in a master’s degree course at the University of Glasgow. 

“I am grateful for the support that UKLFI and the wider Jewish community has provided, and I hope this encourages other students to take action against institutions that do not uphold their responsibility of ensuring academic freedom and fair marking,” Greyman said in the statement. 

“That said, I am disappointed by the waste of resources that went into dealing with the issue. If the University of Leeds had simply apologized at the outset, corrected the marking and offered antisemitism training to staff, I would have felt greatly satisfied. 

“Instead, they failed to confirm that I was entitled to the degree until it was too late, and made me wait six months before hearing my appeal, and then a further six months for the re-marking. This has been a long and emotionally draining process, but it is necessary that large institutions know that they will be held accountable for their wrongdoings,” Greyman said.

Produced in association with Jewish News Syndicate

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.