The controller market is in a great place right now. There are so many brilliant gamepads worth buying out there and, arguably, Xbox is the one to thank for that. Microsoft pioneered the pro controller craze with its Elite pads, and licensing deals for third-party products exist thanks to that.
Ruling the roost since 2019 has been the Elite Series 2, the perfect controller for many people. It took a long time for the rest of the market to catch up to this gamepad, which features four back paddles, swappable thumbsticks, and a lot of great software integration with Xbox machines. Particularly among the best Xbox Series X controllers, it went without a rival for a long time.
Almost five years after its release though, that isn’t the case any longer. I’ve reviewed two controllers recently that arguably overtake it. The Turtle Beach Stealth Ultra and the Victrix Pro BFG for Xbox both sit at $179.99, the same level as the Elite Series 2’s MSRP. They feature four back buttons each, swappable thumbsticks, and if you opt for the BFG, you get a modular design that you can tailor to whichever game you’re trying to excel in. Turtle Beach has microswitches to help with feel, as well as precise vibration, and a swanky display to help you customize it as you play.
These new contenders are both officially licensed for Xbox Series X and S, and they even feature wireless support - something that third-party Xbox pads are typically not allowed to have due to licensing agreements. With such strong contenders emerging, you’d be forgiven for questioning your loyalty to the Elite Series 2. After all, five years on, we should really be thinking about an Elite Series 3 at this point. So, is this highly praised gamepad still worth buying? As someone who reviews controllers, constantly tests out the latest ones, and tracks their prices across two continents, here are my reasons for and against the Elite Series 2 in 2024.
Reason for: Price
The Elite Series 2’s price has been slow to come down over the years since it was one of the first-party Xbox Series X accessories, but it’s currently sitting at $150 at Amazon, down from its listed price of $179.99. That might not seem like a big reduction, but it points to more affordable rates as time progresses.
$150 isn’t exactly cheap, especially not for something that’s five years old. I’d still recommend it because of where it sits in the market though. Those aforementioned products from Turtle Bech and Victrix both sit at the same $179.99 price, so if you can get this first-party option for cheaper, you’re getting a bargain.
If you’re turned off by the price of the Elite Series 2, even when discounted, the Elite Series 2 Core is also an option. It’s the exact same controller, just without the accessories pack you get with the full-fat model. You can still buy this separately, though, so the option is there to upgrade later. In my opinion, the Core model highlights some of the underrated parts of the Elite Series 2 - excellent battery life, remappable buttons on Xbox, and an evolution of the classic Xbox controller feel.
There are even third-party accessories you can buy that will work out slightly kinder to your wallet here. Thanks to the Elite Series 2’s magnetic slots for its back paddles, it's easy to find compatible ones.
Reason against: Longevity
One perk to buying the Turtle Beach Stealth Ultra or Victrix Pro BFG for Xbox is that they both sport Hall Sensor technology. Granted, the anti-stick drift modules of the Victrix Pro BFG come separately and require an additional purchase, but at least the option is there if you ever need it. Turtle Beach threw this fancy magnetic tech in their gamepad from the off, and it means you’re not going to run into thumbstick drift at some point down the line.
We haven’t heard many reports about Xbox’s first-party controllers suffering from this annoying controller plague, but we do know that they use potentiometer thumbsticks, which are susceptible to wear and tear.
If you want to ensure the pro controller you buy is going to last year well into the future, a more modern alternative to the Elite Series 2 might be for you.
Reason for: Where's the Elite Series 3?
For many players, the anticipation of an Elite Series 3 controller might make the thought of buying the Elite Series 2 less appealing. We haven’t heard anything about a new Elite Series controller, which is odd considering the length of time we’ve been waiting. What we have heard are leaks from last year about the Xbox Series X refresh that’s touted to happen soon.
Along with Project Brooklyn, a new controller with haptic feedback reminiscent of a PS5 DualSense is on the way. We know very little about this though, so I wouldn’t hold out on buying a new gamepad because of these unconfirmed leaks.
Given how many Xbox cancelations and studio closures we’ve seen in the last six months, there’s no guarantee that this controller is even still being worked on. Given the solid third-party offering at the moment, the brand likely has bigger fish to fry than a new gamepad. Xbox hardware sales have been lagging behind to such an extent that an Elite Series 3 is hardly going to turn the tide.
I’d still recommend the Elite Series 2 based on how little information we have about new first-party alternatives.
Reason against: Great budget options
Even if we take the options from PDP and Turtle Beach out of the equation, there are loads of third-party Xbox controllers with official licensing that have caught up to the Elite Series 2. Not all of them sport four back buttons, but you can get by in most games with just two. GameSir’s T4 Kaleid controller proved very popular in 2023, and it’s making the leap over to the Xbox field now. Similarly, the GameSir G7 SE and PowerA Advantage Controller are wired but still offer some brilliant pro features for very low prices compared to the Elite Series 2.
With all of those sitting between the $40 and $50 mark, you could buy one of each and still spend around the same as it costs for an Elite Series 2.
Overall, should you buy the Elite Series 2 in 2024?
There are still loads of reasons to buy an Elite Series 2 in 2024. Almost five years on, it’s still one of the best video game controllers money can buy - even if the rest of the field has managed to catch up. You’re getting pro features, a faithful Xbox design, immense battery life, decent value for money, and there’s no confirmed sign of a successor coming up soon.
Equally, there are loads of reasons to buy competitor gamepads too, so shop around and see which has the most expansive feature set and best attachments for you and the games you play. Particularly if you’ve fallen victim to stick drift before, there’s value in going for Hall Sensor tech. Those who like the snappy feel of micro switch buttons might also prefer leaning into devices with them. Then again, if you can actually forgo a lot of the Elite features, budget brands have so much to appease you with.
If you play across multiple genres, and you want to excel in every game you play, a versatile controller with a modular design like the Victrix Pro BFG is for you. If you like tactile feedback and RGB looks, as well as a killer gamepad that works as well in single-player experiences as in multiplayer, look to Turtle Beach’s Stealth Ultra. If you’re a die-hard Xbox fan who wants the most out of their console, don’t seep on the elder statesman that is the Elite Series 2. It’s a steely-eyed veteran who can still take on those younger competitors.
If you’re in no rush and you want to wait and see what Project Brooklyn has in store, then maybe hold off for now. With Xbox hardware sales lagging so far behind PlayStation, a new controller could be one of the aces up Microsoft’s sleeve. If that’s of no interest to you, we’ve used our price comparison software down below to show you the best controller deals in your area.
You can find more controller recommendations by checking out our guides on the best PC controllers, the best PS5 controllers, and the best racing wheels for PC.
