Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Times of India
The Times of India
Sport
Dwaipayan Datta | TNN

IND vs ENG 2nd Test: Team India may be tempted to play four spinners and a lone pacer on Vizag’s black-soil turner

CHENNAI: The ‘spin quartet’. It’s an idea that evokes a sense of nostalgia and respect in equal measure if you’re an Indian cricket fan. But post the late 1970s, when Bishan Singh Bedi, BS Chandrasekhar, Erapalli Prasanna and Srinivas Venkataraghavan retired from the sport, India haven’t gone back to the formula. Now, however, there’s an air of desperation after England’s counter-attacking win in Hyderabad, following which the likes of Monty Panesar are now predicting a 5-0 win in favour of the visitors.

While one defeat can always happen, what’s going to bother captain Rohit Sharma going into the Vizag Test from Friday are the injuries to Ravindra Jadeja and KL Rahul.

Jadeja’s hamstring strain is a huge cause of concern for the Indian team because he is the lethal weapon, along with R. Ashwin, in the Indian spin attack. Axar Patel is more than decent in Indian conditions but it seems England have come with a gameplan for him.

Ashwin and Axar will obviously lead the Indian spin attack on another black-soil turner in Vizag, but former India captain and former chairman of selectors Krishnamachari Srikkanth feels India should play the two other spinners — wrist-spinner Kuldeep Yadav and offie Washington Sundar as well.

Washington was drafted into the squad on Monday after it was revealed that Jadeja would be out for a while. Srikkanth told TOI on Tuesday: “In the first Test, Siraj bowled a total of 11 overs without a wicket. On pitches like these, England have shown that four spinners can be played. What is stopping us from playing all four together as well?” That would mean Washington will be Jadeja’s replacement in the middle order while Siraj will make way for Kuldeep. “If India go in with four spinners, they will have all the variations at their disposal,” Srikkanth said.

The fact that Washington made an instant impact and played a huge role in India’s 2021 Test win at the Gabba is an indicator that he has the necessary temperament to shine on a stage like this.

1/10:India vs England 1st Test: Statistical Highlights

ANI

2/10:​Ollie Pope

<p>Ollie Pope's 196 is his second highest Test score behind the 205 vs Ireland at Lord's in June 2023. </p>IANS

3/10:Joe Root

<p>Just three England batters have amassed more runs in an innings in India - 218 by Joe Root in 2021; 207 by Mike Gatting in 1985 and 201 by Graeme Fowler in 1985 - all three at Chennai. </p>IANS

4/10:​Tom Hartley

<p>Tom Hartley's figures of 7/62 are the fifth best bowling performance against India on Test debut and also the best for an England spinner on Test debut in the post-war era (since 1945). </p>PTI

5/10:9 wickets

<p>Tom Hartley's nine wickets in a match are the joint-most since Robert Berry's 9/116 vs West Indies in Manchester in 1950. </p>PTI

6/10:2nd highest losing 1st innings score

<p>India's total of 436 is their second highest losing first innings score in India, resulting in a defeat behind the 449 against Pakistan at Bengaluru in 2005. </p>PTI

7/10:​Shubman Gill

<p>Shubman Gill averages 17.30 (173 runs in his last 11 innings without a 50), the highest being 36 against South Africa at Cape Town this month) since making 128 against Australia at Ahmedabad (March 2023). </p>AFP

8/10:Defeat for India

<p>190 is the second highest first innings lead resulting in a defeat for India in a Test match - the highest being 192 against Sri Lanka at Galle in 2015. </p>AFP

9/10:4th narrowest Test defeat

<p>This is the fourth narrowest Test defeat for India by runs (28), behind 12 runs vs Pakistan in Chennai 1999, 16 runs vs Australia in Brisbane 1977 and 16 vs Pakistan in Bengaluru 1987. </p>AFP

10/10:England seamers

<p>This is the first instance that there was no wicket for England seamers in a Test in post war era (since 1945), where they have taken all 20 opposition wickets. </p>Reuters
India vs England 1st Test: Statistical Highlights

But another former Indian selector Devang Gandhi feels four spinners is a little too much, even on spin-friendly conditions. “You’ll invariably underbowl one. And I know the Vizag pitch, the ball will become rough and there will be scope for reverse swing. I don’t think it’s a good idea to limit yourself to Jasprit Bumrah as the only pacer,” Gandhi said, adding that Kuldeep for Jadeja should be the only change in the bowling attack.

Patidar or Sarfaraz for Rahul?

Mumbai batter Sarfaraz Khan has got a sudden call-up after Rahul pulled out. He has been in great form, hitting 161 against England Lions a few days ago. “He is an out-of-thebox player, can play the reverse sweep and has been in great form. I think India need a player like that to throw the English spinners off their line and length,” Srikkanth said, adding that if he was in charge, he would have pushed for Patidar as well in place of Shreyas Iyer.

“Iyer isn’t scoring either. Maybe if he fails again, India will go that way after Virat Kohli comes back from his break,” Srikkanth said.

1/10:Ollie Pope, Tom Hartley star as England stun India in opening Test

AP

2/10:Seven-star Hartley shines on debut

<p>Debutant spinner Tom Hartley took seven wickets as England pulled off a dramatic 28-run upset win over India marked by a stellar batting performance by Ollie Pope in the opening Test in Hyderabad on Sunday.<br /></p>Getty Images

3/10:England bowl India out for 202 to register thrilling win

<p>Chasing 231 for victory, India were bowled out for 202 in the final over of an extended third session of play on the fourth day in Hyderabad, as Hartley got Mohammed Siraj stumped with his left-arm spin to trigger celebrations from the England camp.<br /></p>IANS

4/10:Pope stands out with his 196-run knock

<p>Pope stood out with his 196 to bring England bouncing back from being 190 behind at the start of their second innings to lead the five-match series 1-0.<br /></p>AFP

5/10:Hartley dismisses Bharat to grab his five-wicket haul

<p>Hartley, who got his five-wicket haul after he bowled wicketkeeper-batter KS Bharat, kept coming back to return figures of 7-62 and a match tally of nine wickets.</p>PTI

6/10:Hartley scalps Jaiswal, Gill in space of three balls

<p>India started well in their chase, before Hartley struck twice in one over to send back Yashasvi Jaiswal (15) and Shubman Gill (0) in the space of three deliveries.</p>IANS

7/10:Hartley gets rid of India skipper Rohit

<p>Rohit looked good in his knock of 39, but got rapped on the pads by Hartley's darting ball into the right-hander and walked back after his failed review on the lbw.<br /></p>IANS

8/10:India lose Axar soon after tea break

<p>The left-handed Axar Patel (17) was promoted up the order and began attacking the bowling but was dismissed after the tea break and India soon slipped to 119-7.<br /></p>IANS

9/10:Injured Leach sends Iyer back

<p>Premier spinner Jack Leach took the field with an injured knee, after he banged it on day one and two, and bowled 10 overs for the wicket of Shreyas Iyer, for 13.<br /></p>Getty Images

10/10:Hartley dismisses Ashwin to end India's hopes

<p>Bharat and Ravichandran Ashwin attempted to pull things back in their partnership of 57 but Hartley got them out to end India's hopes.<br /></p>Reuters
Ollie Pope, Tom Hartley star as England stun India in opening Test

Gandhi argued in favour of Patidar in place of Rahul, because he was initially chosen in the squad.

“He has a good temperament, I have seen him do well in the IPL. Patidar is a good first-class batter as well,” Gandhi said.\

It’s to be seen what India’s line of thinking will be once they get down to training in Vizag on Wednesday

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.