New York City is one of the most electric places on earth. I love the energy, the pizza, and the people-watching. But let’s be real. It is a massive city, and like any major metropolis, it has predators looking for easy prey. Muggers rarely look for a fight; they look for a victim who is distracted, vulnerable, or flashy. They read body language in split seconds. If you want to enjoy the Big Apple without losing your wallet, you need to stop acting like a target. Here are 10 clues that you are inadvertently painting a bullseye on your back.
1. You Are Walking While Texting
If your head is buried in your phone, you are the perfect target because you are completely unaware of your surroundings. A thief can snatch your device and disappear into the crowd before you even register what happened. In NYC, “apple picking” is common, where thieves on mopeds grab phones from pedestrians and speed off. Keep your head up and walk with purpose. If you need to check a text or a map, stop moving, step into a store, or put your back against a wall to secure your blind spot.
2. You Are Wearing Flashy Jewelry
NYC is stylish, but there is a difference between style and flashing wealth. Wearing a Rolex, a heavy gold chain, or a designer bag with huge logos screams “I have money.” Criminals spot luxury items from a block away and assess the resale value instantly. On the subway or in quieter neighborhoods, tuck the jewelry away and turn your diamond engagement ring inward so only the band shows. Do not advertise your net worth to strangers; save the display for the restaurant or the gala.
3. You Stop in the Middle of the Sidewalk
Nothing screams “tourist” louder than stopping abruptly in the middle of a busy sidewalk to gawk at a building. You signal that you do not know the rules of the road and are disoriented. New Yorkers walk fast, and when you break that aggressive flow, you attract unwanted attention. If you need to look at something, step to the curb and treat the sidewalk like a highway by pulling over before you stop. Blending in is your best defense.
4. You Look Lost and Hold a Physical Map
Retro maps are cute, but standing on a street corner turning a giant piece of paper upside down is dangerous. It acts as a beacon for scammers and shows you have zero idea where you are. Predators watch for this confusion because they know you likely carry cash and vacation money. Study your route before you leave the hotel and use one earbud for GPS voice directions. This allows you to walk with your head up, looking like you know exactly where you are going.
5. Your Bag Is Unzipped or Behind You
Backpacks are convenient, but on a crowded subway train, they are a liability because you cannot see what is happening behind you. Pickpocket teams work in pairs, bumping you to create a distraction while the other dips into your bag. Move your backpack to your front when you are in crowds, a move locals call “turtle style.” Ensure your purse has a zipper closure rather than a magnet snap and keep it tucked tightly under your arm.
6. You Are Sleeping on the Subway
It has been a long day of sightseeing, but do not fall asleep on the train. A sleeping passenger is the easiest mark in the city, allowing thieves to cut pockets or slide bags away without waking you. The subway requires alert attention, especially late at night or when the car is empty. Stay near the center of the train where the conductor operates for safety. If you are exhausted, the extra cost of a cab or Uber is worth it to ensure you get home safely.
7. You Use ATMs on Desolate Streets
Using an ATM at night on a quiet block is risky behavior because you are distracted, holding cash, and have no witnesses. Criminals often watch ATMs from parked cars or corners, waiting for someone to withdraw money. Avoid street-facing machines entirely and only use ATMs inside bank lobbies where you must swipe a card to enter. Alternatively, use machines inside busy convenience stores, and never count your cash on the street.
8. You Are Overloaded with Shopping Bags
Carrying five different shopping bags from high-end stores makes you slow, clumsy, and unable to run. A bag from a luxury boutique also tells a thief exactly where you shopped and that you are carrying high-value items. If you make a big haul, go back to your hotel to drop it off immediately. You can also use a reusable, nondescript tote bag to hide logos so you do not wander the streets looking like a walking department store.
9. You Are Too Polite to Strangers
Muggers often use distraction techniques, asking for the time, a cigarette, or directions to get you to stop and lower your guard. In NYC, it is okay to keep walking because you do not owe a stranger your attention. A simple “sorry” while you keep moving is safer than stopping to engage. Maintain your distance, and if someone invades your personal space, back away loudly because distance provides reaction time.
10. You Walk Too Close to Building Lines
Walking right up against buildings limits your visibility and your escape routes, making it easier for someone to pull you into a doorway. Walk near the curb or the center of the sidewalk to give yourself room to maneuver. This keeps you visible to passing cars and prevents someone from lurking around a corner to surprise you. You want a wide field of vision at all times.
Walk with Confidence, Not Fear
The goal is not paranoia; it is preparation. By eliminating these clues, you stop being a target and start being a savvy traveler. NYC is an amazing place, so own the sidewalk, stay alert, and have the best time.
What is your number one rule for staying safe in a big city? Share your tips below!
What to Read Next…
- NYC’s New Safety Rules: 5 Things You Need to Know in 2026
- The Top 3 Hidden Gem Neighborhoods in NYC Where Safety Is Still the Top Priority
- 7 Reasons That Dating Apps Are Dying a Quick Death in NYC
- 9 Emergency Items Missing from Most Family Cars (But Needed ASAP)
- 10 Safety Tools Women Use That Provide Big Protection For Low Cost
The post Here Are 10 Clues You Are A Target For Being Mugged in NYC appeared first on Budget and the Bees.
