In a significant development in the high-profile Gilgo Beach murders case, the suspect Rex Heumann has been charged with the murder of a fourth victim. Heumann, who is already facing three counts of murder, including that of Maureen Brainerd Barnes, has now been linked to the death of a previously unidentified woman. The latest indictment introduces new DNA evidence, potentially sealing Heumann's fate as the perpetrator of these heinous crimes.
The announcement came as Nicolette Brainerd Barnes, the daughter of Maureen, addressed the court for the first time. Emotionally recounting childhood memories, Nicolette expressed the pain of losing her mother and the void left by her absence. Maureen Brainerd Barnes, who vanished in 2007, is believed to be the first victim of the Gilgo Beach killer. Heumann, who has maintained his innocence, now faces the accusation of killing all four women found in close proximity to each other.
The crucial breakthrough in the case is the discovery of a hair on a belt that was associated with Maureen's murder. Advanced nuclear DNA analysis revealed that the hair matched the DNA profile of Heumann's estranged wife, Aza Ellerup. Prosecutors argue that this finding is significant, as nuclear DNA is highly discriminating and can provide stronger evidence in criminal investigations. The 23-page updated indictment also details additional evidence linking Heumann to the deaths of the four women believed to be sex workers.
According to the prosecution, hair found on Megan Waterman's body and the burlap bindings matches the advanced DNA profile of both Heumann and his wife. Furthermore, a hair discovered on Amber Costello's body matches Heumann's daughter, Victoria. However, Heumann's attorney has raised concerns about the sudden availability of nuclear DNA testing results after being previously informed that such testing was not feasible. The defense is likely to challenge the credibility and reliability of this new evidence.
In addition to the DNA findings, investigators have uncovered further incriminating evidence. Burner phones and computer records indicate communications between Heumann and some of the victims. Moreover, a credit card statement found in a storage locker and cell phone records confirm that Heumann's family was out of town during the time when the murders occurred, granting him ample time to carry out his plans.
The indictment marks a significant step forward in the investigation into the Gilgo Four murders. The victims, who were all part of the local sex work community, were human beings with dreams and loved ones who continue to seek justice. The grand jury investigation has concluded, and Heumann will face his next court appearance next month.
The district attorney has expressed hope that the advanced DNA analysis used in this case can also be applied to the other bodies discovered in the same area. This development raises the possibility of uncovering further information and potentially solving other unsolved cases within the Gilgo Beach investigation. As the legal proceedings progress, the families of the victims hold onto the hope that justice will be served for their loved ones.
