If ever there was and huge incentive for Everton’s players to build upon their magnificent 5-1 away win at Brighton & Hove Albion and get the job done of securing their Premier League survival before the final game of the season then it’s the memories of what Blues went through 25 years ago today.
Bidding to avoid what would be the club’s first relegation in 72 years, Sean Dyche’s side moved out of the drop zone on Monday following what was only their second victory on the road of the campaign and they now host Manchester City and go to Wolverhampton Wanderers before being at home to Bournemouth in their last fixture of 2022/23 on May 28. Boosted by their display at the Amex Stadium, can the Blues current crop get the required points to retain their top flight status without having to face another nervous finale though?
Back in 1994 when Everton stayed up by the skin of their teeth against Wimbledon, the ECHO carried a banner headline screaming: “Never again… please.” Over the next couple of years, the Blues would win the FA Cup – still their last trophy to date – and record their only top half finish in the first decade of the Premier League but somehow in 1998 in was Groundhog Day at Goodison Park.
READ MORE: Jamie Carragher makes Everton relegation prediction as Michail Antonio sends warning
READ MORE: Sean Dyche faces Everton midfield dilemma for Man City after Brighton cameo
The difference was, while the class of 1994 had been underachievers, just 12 months later, eight of the starting XI against Wimbledon defeat Manchester United to taste Wembley glory, Dave Watson, the man who lifted the cup that day, and Cup final substitute Duncan Ferguson were the only survivors from then to face Coventry City. While there were talents like the club’s record signing and England international Nick Barmby plus teenage prospect Michael Ball – now an ECHO columnist of course – many of the supporting cast though just weren’t good enough and it’s no surprise they found them and it was no surprise that they found themselves in relegation danger again going into the final fixture.
Unlike in 1994 when five clubs were in the mix for going down on the last day, this time around it was a straight shoot-out between Everton and Bolton Wanderers, managed by former Blues defender Colin Todd. With one game to go, the Trotters were a point better off than Howard Kendall’s side but Everton had a superior goal difference.
Once again the Blues’ destiny was not in their own hands and they had to better Bolton’s result against a Chelsea side – playing a European Cup-Winners’ Cup final in Stockholm against Stuttgart just three days later – at Stamford Bridge. Having been through the gut-wrenching experience before so recently, many Evertonians didn’t have the stomach to do it all again.
There was talk of Kopites parading a royal blue coffin down Bullens Road while an Everton shirt hanging up at Stanley Dock market that morning had an additional letter G placed next to the sponsors’ logo so it read: “GOne 2 One” – a reference to the imminent threat of demotion from the Premier League to First Division. The tension proved all too much for Blues legend and former captain Brian Labone who was famously photographed wearing his club tie and blazer, pacing up and down the pavement on Goodison Road in the shadow of the Main Stand as the action unfolded inside.
Also unlike in 1994 when Everton stayed up in a blaze of glory after a wretched start, on this occasion they got their noses in front early on, only to proceed to make life difficult for themselves. Just as Barry Horne had proven an unlikely goalscorer from midfield against Wimbledon, upped popped Gareth Farrelly just seven minutes in.
The Irishman had netted just once in 27 games in his debut Blues season until that point – in a League Cup tie at Scunthorpe United back in September – but the ECHO’s David Prentice enthused: “Farrelly has been readjusting his sights at the Park End goal all season. This time he lined up his right foot beautifully and the ball soared into the top corner.”
Clinging on for most of the match – and with Gianluca Vialli putting Chelsea ahead against Bolton on 73 minutes – Everton had the opportunity to wrap things up six minutes from the end when they were awarded what Prentice considered an extremely fortunate penalty.
He said: “Coventry bossed the possession and looked much the likelier scorers – until referee Paul Alcock made a decision quite astonishing in its ineptitude.
“Paul Williams’ tackle on Danny Cadamarteri was beautifully timed. The defender prodded the ball to safety but the official ludicrously pointed to the spot. Nick Barmby ‘98 assumed the Graham Stuart ‘94 mantle but Magnus Hedman made a superb save.”
Things then went from bad to worse and Prentice added: “If Barmby was distraught in the 84th minute, in the 88th minute he was desolate.
“(Former Liverpool and Everton man) David Burrows swung over a cross from the left-flank, Dion Dublin (whose non-signing caused Kendall to resign second time around) rose unimpeded and directed a header which Thomas Myhre flapped into the net.
“Just one more goal from Coventry – or Bolton – would have dumped the Blues into Division One. Instead the only other goal of an amazing afternoon came from Chelsea (Jody Morris in the 90th minute). That was enough to bury Bolton.
“Everton had survived because of another club’s inadequacies rather than their own efforts. It was a grimly fitting way to end a season which has stumbled from one catastrophe to another.”
READ NEXT
The real story of what happened when Abdoulaye Doucoure sat on a ball in Everton warm-up at Man City
Phil Neville sends clear message to Everton on Sean Dyche's future as manager
Kevin Campbell names Everton player who will save club from Premier League relegation
Joleon Lescott sends Pep Guardiola selection warning before Everton vs Man City
Everton have finally responded to three-word plea fans should not have had to make
