Raphaël Jucobin's match report
That’s it from me.
Keep an eye out for Raphael’s report from Lille.
Cracking game (well, mostly it was).
France just too good. Can they win the championship in the next round? We’ll find out in a fortnight.
Cheers all.
Well Gonzalo Quesada disagrees with his skipper:
“I don’t think the score reflects the match.”
I sort of agree given how well they played in the first half, and that France scored with every red zone entry in the opening 40.
But Italy’s inability to land a punch in the second means they were rightly beaten by a hefty margin.
Michele Lamaro is up next. He’s asked if the scoreline is a bit harsh on his team:
The scoreboard is always the truth of the game. I think France was unbelievably good at taking their opportunities. Any little error was a good reaction from their part.
We couldn’t build pressure in the. second half and that took us to the yellow card. Then a little injury so I had to cover a backline spot so it was hard to contain them.
We made too many errors. We couldn’t keep our ball, especially on the line-out. We’re playing one of the best teams in the world so you have to be precise, you have to be accurate and at a very high level. There were moments when we were, but a lot of other moments when we didn’t execute well enough.
Shaun Edwards, France’s defence guru, speaks:
We put in a good performance. It was a real Test match.
The defence at the end was top. Really good and aggressive. It was really good to know the things that you’ve worked on in the week come to fruition.
You have to dig deep at certain times, if you want to be champions of Europe, you have to dig deep.
I would love to be a fly on the wall when Italy debrief.
So much went right but too may basic errors, especially at line-out. Can’t beat top teams when you keep chucking away possession.
A bonus point in Edinburgh will secure the title for France in two weeks.
Here’s the player of the match Emmanuel Meafou:
It was a good team performance. I was blowing out there. I didn’t know I had it in me but I’m blessed and so grateful for the opportunity.
We knew that Italy are a strong team. They never let go. But we believe in our team. We go again next week.
The players speak for themselves. Doesn’t matter the name on the back, everyone works.
We’re working towards the 2027 WC. And we’ll keep working.
We’ll take the week off and we’ll be ready for a big game against Scotland.
Scary thing is France barely got out of third gear. Little more than a 7/10 overall. The forwards were OK. Ramos nowhere near his best. That 10 channel rarely lit up and I thought Attissogbe had a tricky time at fullback.
But when you’re so stacked with world class talent, when you have Dupont, when you have Bielle-Biarrey and a sense of indomitability, then 7/10 is more than good enough to beat most teams.
France soar to the top of the Six Nations table with 15 points from three matches. Perhaps just one more win would be enough to secure the title. They’ll want more than that.
Full-time! France 33-8 Italy
The attack comes to nothing as three French defenders haul the Italian ball carrier over the line and they close out a comfortable win!
Updated
80+2 min: 15 phases and Italy have made no ground.
80 min: One last chance for Italy. They win a penalty and then the line-out five short of France’s line. Where was that accuracy throughout the match? Now they build under the French poles. Seven phases but still short. Can they get over?
TRY! France 33-8 Italy (Gailleton, 78)
Go on then, one more! Incredible how they just flick the switch and can put on points at will. Italy look spent. Attissogbe got it rolling down the right. Then Serin had it on a string as he fizzed it back to the left and kept finding runners. Ramos flung a long spiral to his centre who had a lot of work to do, beating one tackler and then wriggling over the line under the contact of another. Ramos adds the extras and this is becoming a bit of a hiding.
Updated
76 min: Dupont makes way to a standing ovation. He is adored. And rightly so. Thought he was very good today. Not outstanding, but still a solid 8/10 performance. His replacement Serin will feed the scrum on halfway.
75 min: LBB chases after a high ball and spills it on halfway. He is still working his socks off.
TRY! France 26-8 Italy (Drean, 72)
Try on debut! France win the line-out and get a maul on. They eke out a penalty and with Drean in so much space down on the right wing, Ramos kicks into the space ahead. A bounce and a simple catch means the new man is over as he smiles. Ramos makes a tricky conversion look routine.
Updated
Yellow card! Italy (Lynagh, 71)
Tha't’s made things almost impossible now fior Italy. He entered the side of a ruck and then committed a deliberate knock on. Take your pick.
69 min: Lynagh spills a ball in the air but France counter. Dupont then rakes a kick forcing Odogwu to clean up. Italy retain possession from a French kick but they’re turned over on the floor. It’s all happening between the 10m lines either side of halfway.
67 min: Yet another scrum penalty for Italy. I think that’s four for the match. They play with advantage as P Garbisi runs hard and straight. His brother, on at 9, keeps things ticking, but Italy can’t beat the French defence. We go back for the penalty that is kicked out short of the 22. But France pinch that line-out. The Italian line-out has more than malfunctioned. It might be the reason they lose this game.
65 min: A couple of French errors means a little messy passage ends with Italy having the scrum between their 22 and halfway. That was a spill in the air from LBB. But Italy, when they get the ball back, don’t look like breaking the French line. In fact a wild pass in an attempt to rush the play ended in a French hand. The crowd celebrate prematurely but we go back from the knock-on.
64 min: Italy get the ball in and out of the scrum and Capuozzo hoofs it down field. He finds touch beyond the 22.
63 min: Oh France spill the ball! Brau-Boirie! Can’t believe France didn’t score. They kept hammering the line. It felt inevitable. But the centre took his eyes off the ball as his vision was flooded by red jerseys. Italy have the scrum feed five out from their own line.
62 min: France showing some class now. Attissogbe got a lovely off-load away for LBB on his left. They’re nine phases and a metre short. After the backs down the line the forwards get to work. Italy slow it down illegally so France have the penalty under the shade of Italy’s sticks. One more try should prove the winner.
60 min: France have Italy exactly where they want them. The men in red just cannot get out of their half. They’re back in their 22, throwing to a line-out. But it’s skew. Again. So France gifted possession.
57 min: France back on the ball after Italy’s long kick. They kick. They kick again after winning possession. Ioane kicks from deep. Ramos kicks high. Capuozzo fields before Fusco kicks. France win the battle as the Italian scrumhalf hoofs it straight out. France will have the line-out between Italy’s 22 and halfway.
55 min: The referee changed his mind. There was actually a French knock-on in that so Italy have the feed. Garbisi finds Lynagh who is cut down. Italy kick possession away – inexplicably I might add – so France have. the ball inside their half. Dupont shapes to kick but passes. Now he kicks. High and long where Marin takes a tough catch over his shoulder. Italy pinned in their half. They need to show a bit more if they have any design on a comeback. Capuozzo tries from his own 22 but is snaffled.
54 min: Capuozzo counters and is snaffled by two French tacklers. The ball is stolen and France attack from inside Italy’s patch. But the ball is spilled. Scrum to the visitors just beyond their 22. France don’t take the hit so give away the freekick. Garbisi hacks a kick downtown. Italy have it then spill it. French scrum on halfway.
The fluency and energy of the first half has evaporated.
51 min: France don’t win the penalty at the scrum but they spark a move down the line. Attissogbe has it and is tackled. Dupont keeps peppering the blindside but the grubber bobbles out of touch. Italy take the line-out quickly and kick ahead. Cappuozzo and LBB are in a foot race. The Italian is fast but the Frenchman is quicker. He gets there first and Dupont, back inside his 22, boxes down to halfway. Line-out for Italy. This time they win possession. But spill the ball soon after. Went backwards so they build on halfway.
50 min: Italy once again hand possession back with a spill at the line-out. My goodness, that part of their game has just been pants this afternoon! France have the scrum feed. It’s been a bit of a crap shoot at the scrum but they must figure they can eke a penalty from inside their half.
48 min: Italy get the ball out the scrum and Garbisi clears. Attissogbe looks nervy in the backfield but does enough to recycle the ball. Dupont then explodes down the blindside on the right near the touchline and finds Bielle-Biarrey who is motoring upfield. France are cantering until Menoncello runs back and nails Jegou and then gets to his feet to win the turnover. Great stuff from the Italians. If they can score next they’re in with a shout.
46 min: France chuck a forward pass off that first phase strike play from the line-out. Ramos is shaking his head but the referee’s decision is final. Was slick before that with Marchand running hard and Dupont welcoming contact before feeding his 10. Italy have the scrum outside their 22 bang in front.
45 min: Penalty this time fro France at the scrum! If you are a fan of 16 men gathering in a tight space and shoving each other, you are laughing! Credit to the French pack who underlined their credentials there. Ramos shunts this to Italy’s 22 and France get going.
44 min: This time Italy go to the front of the line-out but France pinch it. Italy’s scrum is thrumming but their line-out is faltering. The clearing kick pushes them back inside their half and Fusco hoists a high return box. A strong Italian chase forces the knock-on so they get the scrum feed beyond halfway.
Have I mentioned that it’s been a stodgy start to the second half?
43 min: Another scrum penalty for Italy! My word, what a set piece they have! Garbisi taps this out. It’s not a great kick. He left about 10 metres on that so Italy will only have the throw on France’s 22. Still, an opportunity to strike.
41 min: Attissogbe makes a real mess under a high ball, leaping to catch it. Be he gets underneath and it bounces behind him. He got a touch on the. way so Italy will have the first line-out of the half. They go over the top but it’s incredibly skew and beyond the 15. So We have a French scrum.
Sloppy start to the half from both sides.
Italy had 57% of territory in that half.
I agree with Biggar. If someone out there is watching rugby for the first time they’d wonder why the better team isn’t on top.
Perhaps any other side, one without Dupont and Bielle-Biarrey, would be behind.
But when you have a 9 who can spark things from nothing, and a wing who can turn the lights off and tuck himself in bed for the room goes dark, you don’t need to be at your best to be better than your opponent.
Make sense? Great.
Here come the players which means I can stop rambling.
Second half about to get going!
Reader James knows exactly where Giuseppe Garibaldi would slot in on a rugby pitch:
“Definitely a swashbuckling fly half.”
I’d agree if he played for Italy. If he played for France he’d be a scrum-half.
He was, after all, a literal general.
“Italy must be more accurate,” says their former skipper Segio Parisse on ITV.
Dan Biggar says it’s “been a funny kind of game,” pointing out that Italy have maybe been the better team.
White we munch on our halftime orange, George G wants to remind us of the history between these nations:
You mentioned the Garibaldi Cup. Worth noting Garibaldi was born in Nice when it was still part of the Italian kingdom of Piedmont-Sardinia. So if he was a rugby player I think he’d qualify for both France & Italy.
Nice was handed to France in exchange for French military help in Italian unification so Garibaldi later lamented he’d become a foreigner in his own home town.
Interesting stuff. Wonder what position he’d play?
Half-time: France 19-8 Italy
France almost score with a superb strike move! Dupont missed Ramos off the scrum but the 10 was on the loop and had it off his centre before a delayed pass found Drean on a blind run. The winger darted for the right corner but was shunted out about two metres short.
That bring an energetic half of rugby to a close. Italy can maybe feel slightly hard down by as the score doesn’t quite reflect the flow of the game. But France are so clinical.
Back in a bit.
40 min: Italy spill the restart. How frustrating. That hands France a chance to strike on the visitor’s 22 just before the break.
Penalty! France 19-8 Italy (Garbisi, 40)
A swinging left boot and Italy chip away at the deficit.
39 min: Italy win the scrum penalty! They’ve already handed out lessons to Scotland and Ireland. Now the Italian pack is getting the better of the monstrous French heavies. It’s well within range and Garbisi calls for the tee.
38 min: Italy enjoying a spell on the ball between halfway and France’s 22. But they’re not really going anywhere. France’s defence has them comfortably at arm’s length and, in an attempt to up the ante, Garbisi throws a forward pass. France make a change in the front row ahead of this scrum. Cros makes way for Neti. Another Tolouse man in a team stacked with them.
36 min: Jegou flings a wild pass that is gobbled up by Italy on halfway. Too eager and they get away with it. Menoncello chases the kick but LBB is there to watch ti bobble over the try line and dots down safely.
35 min: France show unreal continuity in close quarters. Dupont found Meafou with a delicious off-load. Eight phases from a scrum on the 22 and they’re a couple of metres short. Gailleton took his eyes off the ball in midfield and Italy manage to push France back to the 22 and come up with the steal! They set themselves up for an exit and Fusco hoofs a kick that is partially charged down. France come again from halfway.
TRY! France 19-5 Italy (Cappuozo, 32)
France shoot themselves in the foot! Credit must go to Italy. They launched a counter down the right with Menoncello who kicked upfield and had the ball stop jus short of the French line. Ramos ran back and flicked it up for Attissogbe who didn’t kick but tried to run it back from his own line. He was swarmed by three Italian cleaners and when the ball bobbled lose the Italian fullback was there to dot down. The conversion from the right of the poles is missed.
What a game we have here!
TRY! France 19-0 Italy (Ramos, 29)
A bolt from le bleu! From nothing. Italy had the line-out but overcooked it, missing their jumpers. France hacked ahead as the ball bounced and it fell into the breadbasket of Gailleton who exploded upfield and away from the chasing Italians. When he ran out of room down the left tram he found Ramos back infield. The 10 pinned his ears down and went for the corner before finishing under contact. Sublime. Three red zone visits. Three tries. Ramos dusts himself off and nails the tricky conversion from the left.
Updated
28 min: Italy win the line-out just beyond France’s 22 and maul it into the red zone. It stalls and Fusco is told to use it. Menoncello hits a lovely line and makes about 10 metres before he’s dragged down. But the ball is pinched! By Dupont! Is there anything he can’t do? So strong to snatch it out of Menconcello’s hands as the Italian centre was held up in the air.
26 min: Italy have it on France’s 22. They’re building. Eight phases. Menoncello on the right. 10 phases. Garbisi hoists a high cross-field into France’s 22 and Drean does really well under pressure to hold on and take the mark.
23 min: Italy close again! Superb down the left wing with Marin bursting through contact and he kept going. Capuozzo was in support. He then found Lynagh who didn’t off-load to the support on his left. The cleaners lost their feet and gave away a penalty five short of the French line. Brilliant but not brilliant enough.
Shortly after France gave away an accidental off-side from their line-out. Think they used to call those a truck and trailer.
21 min: Italy understandably wanted to put pressure on that French scrum but were pinned for going straight on the angle. Ferrari penalised. Ramos missed touch though so Italy can build on halfway.
20 min: Italy come so close from that line-out. It goes swiftly off the top and two lovely delayed passes from Garbisi for blind runners round the corner – first Lynagh off his wing and then centre Marin – has the ball go coast to coast and short about a metre or two from the left corner. They then keep it with the forwards but two carries later the ball is spilled and Meafou hacks a clearance. They’ll come back for a French scrum on their own line.
19 min: Italy win a penalty inside France’s half but turn down the option of taking the three points. Garbisi punts it out to set up a line-out on their right about 20 metres from the try line.
18 min: Italy just about come away with the ball from their line-out, but they can’t punch through midfield. France are bossing the point of contact. Fusco has no choice but to hoist a box. He finds touch over halfway.
17 min: Attissogbe proves he can play at 15 as he comes within a metre of landing a 50-22. Still, that’s a great kick. Pressure on Italy back in their own patch.
TRY! France 12-0 Italy (Meafou, 15)
So clinical! Off the line-out they went down the line. Ramos had a dart himself, coming to within a metre. Both centres Gailleton and Brau-Boirie did likewise. Dupont chucked an overhead pass to Drean on the right wing before moving back infield. Then, with the Italians scrambling, Dupont hit a short pass for Meafou on a good line and nhe barged over from close range. Ramos doesn’t add the extras from right of the sticks.
Updated
13 min: Ramos now nails a 50-22! Poor from Italy. Off first phases Garbisi lifts a nothing kick that Flament grabs and flings to Dupont. He then finds his 10 who lands a wonder kick that dribbles out for a French throw inside Italy’s red zone.
12 min: Ramos overcooks a kick from first receiver off the scrum and its out on the full. Italy will get the line-out in French territory on the 10m line.
11 min: This time Nicotera finds his jumper legally but the ball is lost is contact shortly after. Will be another scrum to France, between their 22 and halfway.
10 min: That was a steal from Menoncello who pinched the ball and stifled the French move. Dupont, on his 22, hoofs it out around halfway. Italy are holding their own.
9 min: Solid scrum from France after a little delay. Attissogbe joins the line but loses it in contact. Goes backwards though so France, through Gaileton, continue. Theres a steal, Zuliani has it and kicks ahead. Italy counter. Attissogbe cleans up on his own 22 and France survive a scare.
7 min: Disappointing from Nicoetera. His first throw is skew and since France contested it’ll be a change of possession. Scrum to France. They could have gone for the line-out. Curious how this goes.
6 min: LBB has it on the left wing and chips and chases and almost gets it. Ramos dictating play. Solid from France. They get the line-out as Italy went back to cover LBB’s kick. France win the ball and set about another attack in the middle of the park. OH! But Italy win a penalty on the floor. Great breakdown work from L Cannone who got over the ball in a flash.
TRY! France 7-0 Italy (Bielle-Biarrey, 4)
Eight matches in a row for LBB! That’s a Six Nations record and my goodness, he is simply unreal! So quick. It was from broken play, Dupont got hold of a loose ball and swifly hoofed ahead. LBB exploded onto the ball, blitzing the covering defence and dotted down. Ramos slots the extras. I think it’s fair to call the French winger a cheat code.
3 min: Italy put a high kick on Attisogbe who doesn;t hold on but the bounce is kind and France keep possesion. Until it’s ripped away and the Italians attack down the left. A big hit from Drean stops momentum. Italy forced back to their 22 and they run it. Capuozzo dances. Energetic start from both teams.
1 min: Capuozzo wins the ball and Italy turn possession. They kick long and France have it back. Dupont, from his 22, kicks as well. Both teams feeling each other out early.
Strange to see Italy in red.
Italian rugby federation (FIR) explained: “The jersey is entirely in ‘ Garibaldi Red ‘, a color reminiscent of the jackets worn by Garibaldi’s soldiers and which has become synonymous with values such as heroism and indomitable spirit, which the Italian athletes perfectly embody on the pitch.”
A reminder that both teams compete for the Giuseppe Garibaldi Trophy, name after the revolutionary who helped forge the unified nation of Italy.
Righto, Garbisi in red kicks off and away we go!
Anthems time.
Is this the best combination of national anthems in our sport?
The players are getting ready to leave the tunnel as we switch over to the commentary on ITV.
This might not be in Paris, but it still looks like the centre of the world.
If I’ve said it once I’ve said it a thousand times, no other nation, even South Africa or New Zealand, put on a show at the rugby like the French do. They just make it feel so epic!
Jalibert is injured!
Bad news for the mercurial 10.
Although it’s hardly a downgrade as Ramos, who has found himself at first receiver this campaign, slots in at 10.
The wonderful Attissogbe shifts fullback (very keen to see how he gets on there) and Dréan comes on at 14.
Did I mention French rugby has deep pockets?
In the last five games between these teams, the team that has scored the first try has won just once.
Slightly warped as France have won four of those, with that aforementioned draw, but it shows that registering the first try doesn’t guarantee success.
Oh, and there are some World Rugby ranking points on offer.
France sits third on the charts, while Italy are in 10th.
Not that it counts for much, but after 51 Tests, France have a 47-3 record against the Italians with just one draw between them.
That came two years ago when Paolo Garbisi hit the post with the last kick of the match as the teams shared the spoils after a 13-13 stalemate.
I covered the MBM in that game. Was a belter. Fingers crossed we get another one.
This might be the first real test of France’s scrum
The Italians dominated both the Scottish and Irish packs and are a formidable force in the set piece.
Danilo Fischetti is one of the form props in the game. But he’s not just a battering ram. He’s pretty handy in the loose too and has made 15 carries this year for more post-contact metres (28) than any other prop.
Some reading on yesterday’s action while we gear up for this one:
If the Opta supercomputer is to be believed, this is as good as over before its started.
The machine that works in mysterious ways informs me that France have a 92.2% chance of winning with a predicted score of 41-18.
Sounds about right to me.
I’ve had a shocker.
As reader Gavin Daly points out, “‘The game is being played in Lille!”
My apologies. That’s corrected.
I hope no travelling fan made the same me!
Updated
Italy team
The lightning feet of Ange Capuozzo returns after a spell out with injury while Italy starts with the same pack that featured in Dublin last Saturday, with Michele Lamaro captaining the side from blind-side flanker.
Capuozzo slots in at fullback, replacing Lorenzo Pani who misses out on the match-day 23 entirely. That’s the only change to the starting XV from last week.
A bunch of regulars are still missing, including Ignacio Brex who remains unavailable for family reasons.
Italy: 15 Ange Capuozzo, 14 Louis Lynagh, 13 Tommaso Menoncello, 12 Leonardo Marin, 11 Monty Ioane, 10 Paolo Garbisi, 9 Alessandro Fusco, 1 Danilo Fischetti, 2 Giacomo Nicotera, 3 Simone Ferrari, 4 Niccolo Cannone, 5 Andrea Zambonin, 6 Michele Lamaro, 7 Manuel Zuliani, 8 Lorenzo Cannone.
Replacements: 16 Pablo Dimcheff, 17 Mirco Spagnolo, 18 Giosue Zilocchi, 19 Federico Ruzza, 20 Riccardo Favretto, 21 David Odiase, 22 Alessandro Garbisi, 23 Paolo Odogwu.
France team
Fabian Galthie has named an entirely new second row and not dropped an ounce of quality.
Those are some deep pockets the French coach has and he’s reached down and plucked out Thibaud Flament and Emmanuel Meafou to replace Charles Ollivon and Mickael Guillard, both of whom drop to the bench. More heft, less jazz then.
It’s the same backline that has done the business so far as Antoine Dupont and Matthieu Jalibert continue to forge the most exciting halfback combo in the game.
On the bench, Peato Mauvaka, Georges-Henri Colombe and Pierre-Louis Barassi come in for Maxime Lamothe, Regis Montagne and Noah Nene.
France: 15 Thomas Ramos, 14 Theo Attissogbe, 13 Emilien Gailleton, 12 Fabien Brau-Boirie, 11 Louis Bielle-Biarrey, 10 Matthieu Jalibert, 9 Antoine Dupont, 1 Jean-Baptiste Gros, 2 Julien Marchand, 3 Dorian Aldegheri, 4 Thibaud Flament, 5 Emmanuel Meafou, 6 Francois Cros, 7 Oscar Jegou, 8 Anthony Jelonch.
Replacements: 16 Peato Mauvaka, 17 Rodrigue Neti, 18 Georges-Henri Colombe, 19 Charles Ollivon, 20 Mickael Guillard, 21 Lenni Nouchi, 22 Baptiste Serin, 23 Pierre-Louis Barassi.
Preamble
It’s already been a weekend of shocks. Not necessarily in terms of results. After all, Ireland are a side still capable of mixing it with the big boys of world rugby and you’d expect Scotland to have the measure of a struggling Welsh outfit.
But did anyone see the shellacking handed out to England on their own patch? And what about the Welsh? Did anyone really predict that they’d be leading right til the 75th minute?
If we can take anything from Saturday’s action its that we can’t take anything for granted. France should romp to victory. They are, for my money, comfortably the second best team in the world and overwhelming favourites to secure a grand slam.
But Italy are no mugs. They’re well coached, tenacious on defence, adventurous on attack and have more than a handful of genuine superstars.
Don’t be too surprised if the visitors in red provide one more shock before we close out the weekend.
Kick-off at 3:10pm in Lille (4:10pm local time).
Teams and updates to come.
Updated
