I’ll leave you with Dave Hytner’s report from Helsinki. Thanks for your company and emails; goodnight!
Lee Carsley's reaction
The team responded really well and scored three good goals. I thought we were a lot better tonight – we played with a lot more control. Looking at the data we’ve just got, we had massive possession, lots and lots of passes, created lots of chances. But I think we can still be better.
Finland were very well organised, with five at the back, and there wasn’t a lot of space. When you have as much possession as we did, you’re always going to get chances from 70 minutes onwards and it was good that the subs made an im pact.
Trent’s quality speaks for itself; he’s more than earned his place. We do get bogged down with whether he’s left-back or right-back but what’s more important is that he gets in effective positions.
Jack (Grealish) was outstanding tonight. I think he’d have been really effective against Greece and I wish we could fast forward and play them next week.
[Do you want the job?] I’ve not really thought that much about it. My remit was to do six games and I’m really enjoying it. I didn’t enjoy it so much in the last two days – I’m not used to losing with an England team and I don’t take losing very well.
My bosses have made it totally clear what they need from me. This job deserves a world-class coach who has won trophies and been there and done it, and I’m still on the path to that.
Jack Grealish's reaction
We could’ve had a few more goals, especially towards the end as the game opened up. It was difficult at times in the first half and we’re a bit gutted to concede at the end, but we needed a win and we got it.
[On his goal] It comes from the manager giving us all the freedom to move around. I play with Angel every day in training and I know what a top player he is. It was a brilliant assist.
[On Alexander-Arnold’s goal] I said to him, ‘If you score this I’ll give you £500’ and he just slapped it in the top bin!
[On Lee Carsley] Whatever happens with the England manager you’ll always have some people saying negative stuff. I don’t really get it. He’s a top, top guy, a brilliant manager and I love playing for him.
Full time: Finland 1-3 England
All over in Helsinki. It wasn’t the most emphatic response from England to Thursday night’s minor fiasco, but they were deserved winners. The pick of the goals was a delicious free-kick from Trent Alexander-Arnold, playing at left-back for the first time in living memory. He was also part of a sporadically shaky defensive performance.
Jack Grealish and Declan Rice scored England’s other goals – Grealish after excellent work from Angel Gomes – before Arttu Hoskonen headed a deserved consolation for Finland.
90 min Grealish’s low cross is cut out by Hoskonen on the six-yard line. He almost gives the ball straight to Foden but eventually manages to clear.
Four minutes of added time.
89 min “Antman isn’t just a super sub,” says Peter Oh. “He’s a superhero sub.”
88 min Madueke hits the side netting at the other end. He’s been a real threat since coming on, and if his decision making improves he could become a seriously good player.
GOAL! Finland 1-3 England (Hoskonen 87)
No clean sheet for Dean Henderson on his first England start. Walta curls a corner to the near post, where Hoskonen gets across Watkins and strains his neck muscles to force a header past Henderson. Not great defending from Ollie Watkins but Finland deserve that goal.
England are caught napping! 💤
— ITV Football (@itvfootball) October 13, 2024
Hoskonen steals in at the front post to nod in for Finland #ITVFootball | #FINENG pic.twitter.com/8uGqqm4CBH
Updated
86 min Though England have been the better team, the scoreline is a little harsh on Finland. Fredrik Jensen missed two chances to equalise, the second a bit of a sitter, and at no stage have they been haemorrhaging chances.
85 min: England substitution Conor Gallagher comes on for Declan Rice.
Rice makes it 3️⃣!
— ITV Football (@itvfootball) October 13, 2024
But this one is all about Ollie Watkins 👏👏👏#ITVFootball | #FINENG pic.twitter.com/SWrHwSsITb
Updated
GOAL! Finland 0-3 England (Rice 84)
Declan Rice makes it three on the break. Watkins made good ground down the left, beat Hoskonen in the area and slid a good low cross towards the near post. Rice, who ran the length of the field in support just in case, touched the ball past Hradecky. That’s his second goal in four games under Lee Carsley.
Updated
82 min: Finland substitution Oliver Antman comes on for Nikolai Alho, who had a good game at right wing-back.
81 min England break four on four. Grealish slips the ball down the left to Foden, who tries to find the unmarked Watkins at the far post. A Finland defender gets back to boot the ball over his own bar.
79 min Walta shoots over from 25 yards, with Henderson committing to a slightly weird dive after the ball has cleared the bar.
England make two more substitutions: Phil Foden and Rico Lewis come on for Jude Bellingham and Angel Gomes. Both played pretty well and Gomes created Jack Grealish’s goal with a lovely pass.
78 min Here’s that terrific free-kick from Trent Alexander-Arnold.
Trent Alexander-Arnold stop that! 😮
— ITV Football (@itvfootball) October 13, 2024
An OUTRAGEOUS free kick from a special talent! #ITVFootball | #FINENG pic.twitter.com/MLF3fElEsH
77 min Bellingham shoots into the side netting from the edge of the area. Hradecky had it covered.
76 min “I’ve only been able to catch snippets of the game, but am intrigued to see Trent playing left back,” says Dean Kinsella. “Has it worked?”
Yes and no, which is the answer to pretty much any question about Alexander-Arnold when he plays for England. Some of his defending has been less than optimal but he played a part in the first goal and scored a majestic second.
Updated
75 min: Double substitution for Finland Teemu Puki and Robin Lod replace Topi Keskinen and Fredrik Jensen.
That was a classic free-kick, whipped over the wall at pace and into the top corner. Hradecky got a touch as he flew to his right but couldn’t keep it out. I don’t think he could have done much more.
Updated
GOAL! Finland 0-2 England (Alexander-Arnold 74)
A beautiful free-kick from Trent Alexander-Arnold seals victory for England.
Updated
73 min Bellingham dummies Walta neatly and is fouled 25 yards from goal. The free-kick is a fair way to the left of centre, with Alexander-Arnold over it…
72 min “The mid-range football nations can get pretty far if they’re well organised, and have a solid goalkeeper and a dangerous striker,” writes Kári Tulinius. “The Eagle-Owls have a clear way of playing, Hradecky is one of the best in the Bundesliga, but since Pukki got old, they lack a cutting edge. Pohjanpalo has been great for Venezia, but hasn’t replicated that form for the national team.”
Updated
71 min Madueke beats his man easily on the edge of the area and tries to give Watkins an open goal with an early cross. Hradecky throws himself at the ball and just manages to touch it away.
70 min Grealish runs at Alho to win a corner for England, who have had a whopping 78 per cent possession in the second half.
69 min: Double substitution for England Ollie Watkins and Noni Madueke come on for Harry Kane and Cole Palmer. Both men had quiet games.
65 min It sounds like Ollie Watkins is getting ready to come on for England, whose domination of this game is verging on the sterile.
Updated
64 min: Double substitution for Finland Leo Walta and Joel Pohjanpalo replace Rasmus Schuller and Fredrik Kallman.
63 min England continue to move the ball from side to side, looking for an opening. Grealish’s goal is about the only time they have found an eye in the Finnish needle.
59 min Rice hits a powerful curler from 25 yards that is held by Hradecky, diving to his left.
57 min Bellingham escapes on the left at the other end and slides a low cross that is crucially cut out at the near post by Hradecky. Kane was waiting behind him and would have had an open goal.
56 min: Great chance for Jensen! Finland should be level. The chance came on the break after about five minutes of non-stop England possession. Keskinen lost Walker on the left side of the area and slide a precise low cross that was wafted over the bar by Jensen, barely six yards out. Replays show the ball bobbled but even so, that was a glorious chance.
Updated
54 min Palmer plays a good early ball to Kane, who releases Walker on the right. He has to wait for support and the move eventually peters out.
51 min And that’s his second. Palmer hits an early shot through the crowd from the edge of the area, and Hradecky gets down well to his right to save.
50 min Alexander-Arnold whistles a decent effort from 30 yards that is held low to his right by Hradecky. That’s his first save of the match.
Updated
47 min Finland break three on three after England lose the ball in midfield. Keskinen finds Kallman, who runs into trouble and is dispossessed. That was an opportunity.
46 min Peep peep! The second half is under way; no changes on either side.
Half-time reading
Half time: Finland 0-1 England
England lead through Jack Grealish’s fourth goal for his country, made stylishly by Angel Gomes. They’ve been good at times, sloppy at others, and a resourceful Finland side have had good chances of their own.
See you in 10 minutes for the second half.
Updated
45 min Kallman’s shot on the turn is saved by Henderson, though he was fractionally offside so it wouldn’t have counted anyway.
43 min Bellingham overruns the ball in the area after receiving a sharp pass from Grealish on the left. That was half a chance.
42 min Finland have played well in the first half and been more competitive than most of us expected.
40 min Kallman heads over the bar after pulling off Guehi in the area. It was a difficult chance as the ball into him was played from a central position.
39 min “Hang on,” says Matt Dony. “Are we saying that you can’t believe everything that’s posted on Twitter?”
Politicians telling bald-faced lies is bad enough, but tactical misinformation is a new low for humanity.
38 min: Good chance for Jensen! A crossfield pass from left to right is headed back infield by Alho towards Jensen on the edge of the area. He runs through the challenge of Alexander-Arnold and splatters a half-volley over the bar. That was a really good opportunity.
36 min Most of England’s threat has been on the left-hand side, with Grealish, Bellingham and Alexander-Arnold seeing a lot of the ball.
35 min Bellingham, on the left, pings a terrific flat pass over the defence to find Rice in the area. He controls the ball in mid-air, inadvertently wrongfoots a defender in the process and has a snapshot that is blocked by a second defender and goes behind for a corner.
Updated
33 min Then England lose the ball and Finland break. The lively Keskinen runs at Stones and shoots straight at Henderson from the edge of the area.
32 min England keep the ball for 90 seconds or so to calm everything down. It does feel like they have another gear or two should they need them.
30 min “Some insider info: Finland was planning to play with a back five all along,” says Antti Vanhoja. “The commentators on Finnish TV were aware of the ruse and revealed it to the audience already before kick-off. A cunning plan, though not very effective.”
It’s a big sad that the culture of marginal gains has extended to deliberately putting your team in the wrong formation when you post it on Twitter, but you see it happen all the time.
Updated
29 min Keskinen’s shot takes a deflection off Walker and spins behind for a corner. Finland are having a good spell.
29 min Play resumes and Jensen has a shot on the turn from about 20 yards that is blocked. Gomes seems okay for now.
28 min There’s a break in play while Gomes receives treatment. It looks like he strained something while trying to challenge Jensen.
25 min Keskinen gets away from Walker and pings a decent cross into the middle. Kallman is the only Finland player in the box, however, and it’s nowhere near him.
23 min Grealish and Bellingham are combining a lot in the inside-left channel. England could still do with an overlapping left-back, but they have what they have.
23 min “All this messing with Trent isn’t doing him, or the team any good,” says Colum Farrelly. “Play him at right back. Or, in the absence of a fit left back, play him at left back. But omit the right-back-with-a-bit-of-midfielder, the left-back-with-free-role (wha?) and if he’s not playing well, don’t play him. Then he’ll know what he’s supposed to do and have a chance to do it well.”
21 min The last man Guehi shows excellent pace to beat Alho to a long ball forward. He looks very assured at this level.
Updated
19 min I know it’s only Nations League Group B2, but that eye-of-the-needle pass from Gomes was very classy.
Back in the team, back on the scoresheet for Jack Grealish ⚽️
— ITV Football (@itvfootball) October 13, 2024
That pass from Angel Gomes needs some love though 😍#ITVFootball | #FINENG pic.twitter.com/tY9LFzDz8L
Updated
Jack Grealish gets his second goal under Lee Carsley. Alexander-Arnold played a short pass into Gomes, 25 yards from goal. He controlled it on the half turn and flicked a gorgeous through ball for Grealish, who timed his run perfectly and passed the ball under Hradecky.
Updated
GOAL! Finland 0-1 England (Grealish 18)
Jack’s back.
Updated
17 min Jensen is penalised for a challenge on Bellingham, complains to the referee and receives an extravagant, arm-waving reprimand. You had to be there.
15 min Finland have done well so far to deny England space in the final third. It helps that England’s play has been quite relatively narrow. I do think that’s a problem the new manager needs to address.
13 min Incidentally, Topi Keskinen, who almost gave Finland the lead in the seventh minute, has a tattoo of Wayne Rooney on his person.
11 min A corner from Palmer is only half cleared by Finland. Alexander-Arnold walks onto the ball, 25 yards from goal, and hits a low drive that is kicked away. He didn’t catch it perfectly and looks frustrated with himself.
10 min The first bit of really good play from England. Grealish slides a crisp return pass into Bellingham on the edge of the area. He twists Jensen (I think) one way and then the other before hitting a shot that deflects off Jensen and spins behind for a corner.
8 min Now England almost get into trouble when Alexander-Arnold gives the ball away. A couple of moments of sloppiness from England.
7 min: Chance for Finland! All that passing from England and it’s Finland who almost take the lead. Gomes gave the ball away to Kamara, and seconds later Stones had to make a desperate sliding block from Kallman’s shot. The ball ran loose to Keskinen, who mishit his shot wide of the near post.
4 min Loads of early possession for England, which comes as no surprise. Trent Alexander-Arnold is almost playing as a left-back with a free role. Imagine if you’d pitched that idea to Jackie Charlton in the 1990s.
Updated
1 min Peep peep! England, in their dark raisin/sesame (sic) change strip, kick off from right to left as we watch. Finland have started with a back five, not the advertised 4-3-3. They literally lied on their Twitter feed.
𝐀𝐯𝐚𝐮𝐬𝐤𝐨𝐤𝐨𝐨𝐧𝐩𝐚𝐧𝐨 – 𝐒𝐭𝐚𝐫𝐭𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐗𝐈 | Nations League: 🇫🇮 v. 🏴 | Huuhkajat tänään kolmen leijonan kimppuun! 🦉🔥
— Huuhkajat (@Huuhkajat) October 13, 2024
Päävalmentaja Markku Kanerva on nimennyt avauskokoonpanonsa klo 19.00 loppuunmyydyllä Olympiastadionilla alkavaan otteluun! Lähetys Yle TV2:ssa… pic.twitter.com/eWVuoa37Ln
Updated
As the players stroll onto the field, here’s a reminder of the two teams.
Finland (possible 4-3-3) Hradecky; Alho, Hoskonen, Ivanov, Uronen; Kamara, Schuller, Peltola; F Jensen, Kallman, Keskinen.
Substitutes: Joronen, Sinisalo, Galvez, Antman, Lod, Pukki, Stahl, Pikkarainen, Tenho, Nissila, Pohjanpalo, Walta.
England (possible 4-2-3-1) Henderson; Walker, Stones, Guehi, Alexander-Arnold; Gomes, Rice; Palmer, Bellingham, Grealish; Kane.
Substitutes: Pickford, Pope, Lewis, Foden, Gordon, Gallagher, Colwill, Livramento, Watkins, Solanke, Madueke.
Referee Giorgi Kruashvili (Georgia).
A bit of pre-match reading
Finland manager Markku Kanerva speaks to ITV
We want to give our fans a spectacular match. We know how tough it’s going to be but we’re ready to make a miracle. We have to defend well for 90+ minutes, be very solid and compact, and take care of the ball when we have it.
“Interesting quote from Carsley on wanting to try something different,” says Joe Pearson. “Is that a coded way of saying it was an object lesson to all those that thought Southgate was too stodgy and conservative?”
I’m not sure that’s how he works. I suspect it was more in the spirit of the England cricket team, testing the boundaries of what’s possible. That’s quite admirable because he’s smart enough to have known what was coming if it went wrong.
England’s Nations League campaign concludes in November with matches against Greece (A) and Ireland (H), then the speculation about Gareth Southgate’s successor will really begin. That’ll be fun.
Remember when
On the scoresheet against Finland at Anfield in 2001: @themichaelowen and David Beckham ⚽️⚽️ pic.twitter.com/8DUBw9CdWm
— England (@England) October 13, 2024
Lee Carsley speaks to ITV
It’s fair to say we fell below the levels that we expect. We can use it as a real positive now with a good response tonight.
[On Dean Henderson’s selection] It was always the case we we were gonna look at Dean in one of the games.
[On Trent Alexander-Arnold at left-back] His role will be a bit different to a conventional left-back. He’s very versatile and we’ve got a lot of confidence in him.
[On the reaction to Thursday’s defeat] I’m absolutely fine. It was something I was expecting – I wanted to try something different and I take full responsibility. If I had my time again I’d do exactly the same.
Jonathan Liew on England
For years the focus of England’s cultural development has been on how we can keep these guys happy, in an era where the rewards and prestige are ever more severely weighted towards club football. This was one of Gareth Southgate’s great achievements, and by the end even he seemed a little lost in the cosmos, desperately trying to keep the circus on the road, a cast of stars all convinced they were possessed of some unique main-character energy.
When it works, your stars step up at crucial moments to drag you to a major final you had no business being in. But the problem with this model is that effort becomes contingent on circumstances. Euro semi-final: fine. Uefa Nations League group B2 in October: good luck with that. Which is why a certain arrogance, a certain caprice, seems to have crept into the setup.
Poor bloke probably can’t wait to get back to the under-21s.
A first #ThreeLions start for @deanhenderson 💚
— England (@England) October 13, 2024
He'll earn his second England cap, having come off the bench for his debut against Republic of Ireland 1,431 days ago! pic.twitter.com/qKNPLpU2PE
Team news: Carsley makes six changes
All change in the England team, with Lee Carsley reverting to a more familiar 4-2-3-1 formation. Harry Kane, Marc Guehi, Kyle Walker, Angel Gomes, Jack Grealish and Dean Henderson replace Phil Foden, Levi Colwill, Rico Lewis, Jordan Pickford, Anthony Gordon and Bukayo Saka.
That means either Walker or, more likely, Trent Alexander-Arnold will start at left-back.
Finland have made five changes to the side that lost at home to Ireland on Thursday.
Finland (possible 4-3-3) Hradecky; Alho, Hoskonen, Ivanov, Uronen; Kamara, Schuller, Peltola; F Jensen, Kallman, Keskinen.
Substitutes: Joronen, Sinisalo, Galvez, Antman, Lod, Pukki, Stahl, Pikkarainen, Tenho, Nissila, Pohjanpalo, Walta.
England (possible 4-2-3-1) Henderson; Walker, Stones, Guehi, Alexander-Arnold; Gomes, Rice; Palmer, Bellingham, Grealish; Kane.
Substitutes: Pickford, Pope, Lewis, Foden, Gordon, Gallagher, Colwill, Livramento, Watkins, Solanke, Madueke.
Referee Giorgi Kruashvili (Georgia).
Your #ThreeLions to face Finland! 📝 pic.twitter.com/d2m4Z8VtQU
— England (@England) October 13, 2024
Updated
Preamble
The difference a game makes. There was plenty of goodwill towards Lee Carsley after his first window as England’s interim manager, with the BBC among those surmising that the job was his to lose. All that goodwill evaporated on Thursday night, when England were beaten by Greece after Carsley picked an, a-hem, experimental XI that inccluded five forwards and no striker.
Carsley was praised by many before the game for letting England’s hair down, then ridiculed after it for being a bald fraud. And while it’s almost entirely unfair, Carsley’s distinguished England coaching career will probably now be remembered for the night he gambled on a 4-1-5-0 formation.
“You want the public to trust and love the team,” said Carsley, “because the impact the national team has on the public is very inspiring. We know we can do a lot better. You have to respect people’s opinions and we didn’t perform as well as we can and I would expect a reaction against Finland.”
England will pick a more conventional team in Finland, with Harry Kane likely to return up front, and they yet could end the day joint-top of Group B2. That would require the Republic of Ireland to win in Greece but, as England know all too well, stranger things have happened.
Kick off 5pm.
Updated
