From Judge David Alan Ezra (W.D. Tex.) today in Wilkins v. Seraphin:
This case arises from allegedly defamatory statements made by Defendant Kyle M. Seraphin on his podcast show, the Kyle Seraphin Show, about Plaintiff Alexis Wilkins ….
Plaintiff Alexis Wilkins [alleges she] "is a patriotic, conservative, Christian, country music artist and published writer, who also works for a conservative advocacy and educational company, PragerU." Since January 2023, Plaintiff has been in a long-term relationship with Kashyap "Kash" Patel, the Director of the … FBI ….
Defendant Kyle M. Seraphin is a U.S. Air Force veteran and former FBI special agent in the FBI's Counterterrorism Division. A self-proclaimed "Podcaster," "Whistleblower," and "Recovering FBI agent," Defendant hosts the Kyle Seraphin Show, during which he "trades on his insider knowledge of the FBI and his experience in law enforcement" to tell his audience the "uncomfortable truth."
The show, which is livestreamed on YouTube, "Rumble," and Defendant's website, garners wide reach. According to Plaintiff's Complaint, Defendant has over 271,800 followers on X, and his posts frequently reach tens of thousands of views and numerous re-posts. Plaintiff also alleges that Defendant receives income through his video sponsorships, paid membership through YouTube, and donations through YouTube.
On August 22, 2025, Defendant stated the following on the Kyle Seraphin Show:
[FBI Director Kash Patel] has had his own little 'honeypot' issue that's been going on of late, so we're just going to acknowledge it real publicly. He's got a girlfriend that is half his age, who is apparently is both a country music singer, a political commentator on Rumble, a friend of John Rich through Bongino, who also now owns a big chunk of Rumble, and she's also a former Mossad agent in what is like the equivalent of their NSA. But I'm sure that's totally because, like, she's really looking for like a cross-eyed, you know, kind of thickish built, super cool bro who's almost 50 years old who's Indian in America.
Like it has nothing to do with the fact that uh we're really close to the Trump administration. Anyway, I'm sure that's totally just like love.
That's what real love looks like.
Plaintiff alleges that, in making this statement, Defendant falsely and maliciously characterized her as a "honeypot"—which she defines as an agent of a foreign government who began a relationship with another for purposes of manipulating and compromising them—and accused her of "conduct[ing] espionage to undermine [] national security" and "committing treason." …
The court concluded that Wilkins had adequately alleged that the statements about her were false factual assertions (rather than opinion or hyperbole); recall that at this stage, the question is just about whether the allegations are legally sufficient—determining their truth or falsity is for later in the case:
