Everton have received a lift in their fight to avoid relegation after a record 10-point deduction for a breach of Premier League profit and sustainability rules (PSR) was reduced to six points on appeal.
The Merseyside club have risen two places to 15th in the table on 25 points, five clear of Luton who are in the final relegation place.
Everton were hit with the biggest sporting sanction in Premier League history in November for breaching financial rules by £19.5m up to 2021-22. The club, having long denied any breach, admitted during October’s hearing to breaking the permitted £105m losses over a three-year period by £9.7m. The club still face a second Premier League charge for the period ending 2022-23.
The appeal board reduced the 10-point penalty on the grounds that the commission made legal errors when imposing the original sanction. The commission was wrong, it said, to say Everton had been “less than frank” over how its new stadium was being funded even though the club had erred in how it represented the costs. The commission should also have considered available benchmarks for the level of punishment, namely in the EFL, when deciding the proportionality of the sanction.
However, the board rejected seven of Everton’s nine grounds for the appeal including that losses connected to sponsorship deals with the sanctioned oligarch Alisher Usmanov, interest on loans that the club claimed were taken out for the stadium and a £10m hit on “Player X”, whose contract was terminated after he was arrested on suspicion of child abuse, were mitigating factors.
Everton said: “While the club is still digesting the appeal board’s decision, we are satisfied our appeal has resulted in a reduction in the points sanction.
“ We understand the appeal board considered the 10-point deduction originally imposed to be inappropriate when assessed against the available benchmarks of which the club made the commission aware, including the position under the relevant EFL regulations, and the nine-point deduction that is imposed under the Premier League’s own rules in the event of insolvency.
“The club is also particularly pleased with the appeal board’s decision to overturn the original commission’s finding that the club failed to act in utmost good faith. That decision, along with reducing the points deduction, was an incredibly important point of principle for the club on appeal. The club, therefore, feels vindicated in pursuing its appeal.
“ Notwithstanding the appeal board’s decision, and the positive outcome, the club remains fully committed to cooperating with the Premier League in respect of the ongoing proceedings brought for the accounting period ending in June 2023.
“The club is still considering the wider implications of the decision and will make no further comment at this time other than to place on record its thanks to our Fan Advisory Board and other fan groups throughout this process, and to all Evertonians for their ongoing support and patience.”
Everton argued the 10-point deduction was “wholly disproportionate and unjust” and that the original commission was wrong to dismiss several mitigating factors for the losses. The club hired the KC Laurence Rabinowitz to lead the appeal, which was heard by a different three-person commission from 31 January to 2 February, and successfully argued against the scale of the punishment. No new evidence was allowed to be presented.
- Download the Guardian app from the iOS App Store on iPhone or the Google Play store on Android by searching for 'The Guardian'.
- If you already have the Guardian app, make sure you’re on the most recent version.
- In the Guardian app, tap the Menu button at the bottom right, then go to Settings (the gear icon), then Notifications.
- Turn on sport notifications.
The Premier League stated “it is satisfied with today’s decision and that the independent disciplinary process, clearly set out in its rules and agreed by all clubs, has been followed throughout”.
October’s hearing rejected Everton’s arguments that interest on loans taken out during the construction of the club’s new stadium, Covid’s impact on player sales and the loss of sponsorship deals with companies connected to the oligarch Usmanov, who had sanctions imposed, should be used in mitigation for their losses. The club had also cooperated with the Premier League over its PSR calculations and transfer policy only to be charged by the organisation with a single breach in March 2023.
Everton’s appeal centred on the regulatory process that resulted in a 10-point deduction and the club’s success raises more questions for the Premier League about its governance. In August, five months after charging Everton, the Premier League and its chief executive, Richard Masters, proposed a six-point sanction as a starting point plus one extra point for every £5m lost. The commission rejected the Premier League’s line of argument but imposed a 10-point deduction in line with Premier League wishes.
Masters told a culture, media and sport committee hearing last month that the Premier League’s sanction policy was left to an independent panel. He rejected a DCMS request to provide the minutes of the meeting in August 2023 when the league agreed its sanctions proposal. “Being a private business, it is not our practice to provide or publish minutes of Premier League board meetings,” he wrote. “Nor are we able to publish submissions the Premier League board or executive make as part of confidential legal proceedings.”
The mayor of Greater Manchester, Andy Burnham, had accused the Premier League of “regulatory malpractice” in attempting to introduce a punishment specific to Everton’s case midway through the disciplinary process and said the 10-point deduction should be declared null and void.
Everton’s second charge should be dealt with before the end of the season.
| Pos | Team | P | GD | Pts |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Liverpool | 26 | 38 | 60 |
| 2 | Man City | 26 | 33 | 59 |
| 3 | Arsenal | 26 | 39 | 58 |
| 4 | Aston Villa | 26 | 21 | 52 |
| 5 | Tottenham Hotspur | 25 | 14 | 47 |
| 6 | Man Utd | 26 | 0 | 44 |
| 7 | Brighton | 26 | 8 | 39 |
| 8 | Wolverhampton | 26 | 0 | 38 |
| 9 | Newcastle | 26 | 9 | 37 |
| 10 | West Ham | 25 | -8 | 36 |
| 11 | Chelsea | 25 | 1 | 35 |
| 12 | Fulham | 26 | -6 | 32 |
| 13 | Crystal Palace | 26 | -13 | 28 |
| 14 | AFC Bournemouth | 25 | -14 | 28 |
| 15 | Everton | 26 | -6 | 25 |
| 16 | Brentford | 25 | -9 | 25 |
| 17 | Nottm Forest | 26 | -14 | 24 |
| 18 | Luton | 25 | -16 | 20 |
| 19 | Burnley | 26 | -33 | 13 |
| 20 | Sheff Utd | 26 | -44 | 13 |
