Emmerdale fans pointed out a problem with little Kyle Winchester's version of events as the boy finally broke down and confessed to police that he - and not Cain - was responsible for the murder of Al Chapman.
Kyle ended up being interviewed by the police on Friday night's episode as mum Amy Wyatt watched on.
But there were a couple of things that stumped Emmerdale fans, including why Kyle's surname is Winchester and the version of events surrounding Al's murder that Kyle told police.