Spoilers are ahead for Episode 4 of Elsbeth Season 3 on CBS, called "Ick, A Bod" and available streaming now with a Paramount+ subscription.
The spooky season came to Elsbeth in the fall 2025 TV schedule, and the leading lady managed to surpass her Breakfast at Tiffany's look from Season 2 by wearing several costumes in honor of My Fair Lady's Eliza Doolittle. It was fitting that the killer guest star of the week was Broadway regular Annaleigh Ashford, although she was chopping heads more than belting notes for "Ick, A Bod." I was surprised to see how quickly Elsbeth let Sharon (Ashford) know that she was onto her as the killer, especially in the aftermath of last week's twist with Kaya. Luckily, Elsbeth did bond with somebody, and it was a joy to watch in the Halloween episode.
