Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - UK
The Guardian - UK
Business
Graeme Wearden

Davos day two: Global tax deal delayed; Von der Leyen on Russian food ‘blackmail’ – as it happened

Davos World Economic Forum Achim Steiner David Beasley Jens Stoltenberg European Commission Frans Timmermans NATO Ursula von der Leyen Ukraine
Special police on guard on the roof of the Congress Hotel at the 51st annual meeting of the World Economic Forum.
Police on guard on the roof of the Congress Hotel at the 51st annual meeting of the World Economic Forum. Photograph: AP

Time to wrap up..... back tomorrow! GW

Early detection will be crucial to prevent an virus outbreak going global and becoming the next pandemic, Bill Gates says.

You also need a global capacity looking out for threats, and responding to them, he tells a panel at Davos.

Gates also flags that many of the pandemic risks are in countries which in the next several decades won’t have the infrastructure needed to handle an outbreak - so international cooperation is crucial.

Helen E. Clark, chair of the WHO’s Partnership for Maternal, Newborn & Child Health, warns that political resolve for co-ordinated change is is waning, while many people are now over Covid.

Rwanda’s president, Paul Kagame, says Africa’s experience fo Covid shows that fixing capacity issues in testing, treatment, and vaccine production is crucial, as is co-operation between countries, and avoiding being dependend on others.

AFP have a good piece on how the pandemic and the Ukraine war are putting globalisation at risk: here’s a flavour:

Globalisation is “temporarily pausing”, Loic Tassel, president for Europe at the consumer goods giant Procter & Gamble said during an event at Davos.

“The price to pay or the time to wait is not compatible anymore with our industry,” Tassel said, giving the example of Shanghai, which is the world’s busiest container port.

“We are now bringing into the equation the cost and resilience of the supply chain, it was not in our mind three years ago.”

But rather than talk about “deglobalisation”, Pamela Coke-Hamilton, director of the Geneva-based agency International Trade Centre, preferred to speak about diversification and relocalisation - where supply chains are closer and in areas where conflict is far away.

“The change will come by the shifting to near sourcing value chains,”

Sceptics said companies sought the cheapest options despite being aware of the risk of huge dependence on certain regions.

“We never imported so much from China as when we said we should rely on it less,” noted Gilles Moec, chief economist at French insurance giant Axa, on the sidelines of Davos.

“One of the reasons why people are so nervous right now is that if China was unable to meet global demand because of the pandemic, that would be a catastrophe.”

The delay to implementing the OECD’s international tax deal is another blow to the multilateral world order, points out the FT’s Chris Giles:

Updated

YouTube CEO Susan Wojcicki on slowdown, Russia, and Roe v Wade

Susan Wojcicki, CEO of YouTube, says there are some worrying economic signs - but she isn’t planning to slash investment.

In a session at Davos now, Wojcicki says there are a lot of concerning macro economic trends, such as the Ukraine war and inflation in the US.

But YouTube, and parent company Google, is taking a long-term view and still sees lots of growth.

When you go through a downturn, it’s important to keep that long-term view, says Wojcicki, a veteran of two recessions at Google (she was the 16th employee).

We may delay some projects, Wojcicki suggests, but YouTube is still an important business so there’ll still be investment.

Having been through a couple of recessions at Google, Wojcicki says a downturn can sharpen a business, as it’s easy to say everything is good when your numbers are going up all the time.

YouTube is still operating in Russia, but suspended advertising back in March. Wojcicki says YouTube has made some ‘incredibly tough’ decisions, as it was aware that information can be weaponised, so wanted the right policies and enforcement in place.

It decided to suspend Russian state-owned media globally, and any post that denies or trivialises war in Ukraine now violates its rules.

By staying in Russia, it is able to deliver independent news into the country -- the average user in Russia can access, for free, the same information as you can in Davos, Wojcicki says.

[The Guardian reported yesterday that YouTube has taken down 70,000 videos and 9,000 channels related to the war in Ukraine]

Wojcicki also reveals that she sets screen time limits for her children, as you want to have a balance.

She’s also asked about the leaked draft Supreme Court ruling overturning Roe v Wade, the 1973 case that guaranteed the right to abortion.

Wojcicki says she believes women should have a choice when they become a mother, and that reproductive rights are human rights.

Speaking personally, she explains that:

To take away a law and a right that we’ve had for almost 50 years would be a big setback for women, but that’s my personal view.

But as a business leader running a company that supports free speech, there should be a broad range of opinions on YouTube. Everyone should be able to express their point of view (within community guidelines).

Updated

Historic OECD international tax deal pushed back to 2024

The historic deal to force the world’s biggest companies to pay a fair share of tax has been delayed until 2024.

Mathias Cormann, the OECD secretary-general, told the World Economic Forum that the deal, which was originally set for implementation in 2023, had fallen behind schedule.

He said there were “difficult discussions” over plans to reshape the global tax system, to let countries levy more tax on the world’s largest firms based on the sales generated within their borders.

The deal - which Cormann called “historic and very important” - has two parts.

Pillar 1 covered the reallocation of some profits from major multinationals such as US tech companies to countries where they made their sales, while Pillar 2 brings in a global minimum corporation tax rate of 15%.

Cormann explained that there are “still some difficult discussions underway with relation to the technical aspects” of Pillar 1.

We deliberately set a very ambitious timeline for implementation to keep the pressure on and we think that has helped keep the momentum going.

But I suspect it is probably most likely that we will end up with a practical implementation from 2024 onwards.”

Pillar 1 is facing opposition in the US Congress from Republican senators, and analysts have suggested the deal could fall if the Democrats lost control of the House of Representatives in November’s mid-term elections.

Pillar 1 required an international treaty to be agreed, while Pillar 2 is implemented through domestic legislation.

Cormann wouldn’t comment on political issues, but argues that the OECD deal would be better for US multinational companies than a proliferation of different tax regimes overseas if countries tried to individually make them pay a fair share.

He was also “very encouraged by the progress” on Pillar 2, and hopeful that EU members will agree to back it.

Cormann argues that once you have a critical mass of countries imposing a minimum level of corporate tax on profits generated in their juristictions, it’s very hard for other countries not to follow.

He explained:

“Essentially you leave money on the table for other countries to collect, if you don’t align yourself to that global standard.”

Poland has been holding back suport for the EU’s directive, but French finance minister Bruno Le Maire said today he is confident agreement will be reached.

Le Maire told reporters before an Economic and Financial Affairs Council in Brussels.

“I’m confident this minimal tax rate project will be adopted unanimously on June 17, that is the goal.”

Kerry: Ukraine crisis can't be excuse for backtracking on climate goals

John F. Kerry, Special Presidential Envoy for Climate of the United States of America, Catherine MacGregor, Chief Executive Officer, ENGIE Group, France, Frans Timmermans, Executive Vice-President for the European Green Deal, and Fatih Birol, Executive Director, International Energy Agency, Paris, on a panel session today.
John F. Kerry, Special Presidential Envoy for Climate of the United States of America, Catherine MacGregor, Chief Executive Officer, ENGIE Group, Frans Timmermans, Executive Vice-President for the European Green Deal, and Fatih Birol, Executive Director, International Energy Agency, Paris, on a panel session today. Photograph: Laurent Gilliéron/EPA

Across the Davos congress centre, US climate envoy John Kerry has insisted that the energy crisis caused by the Ukraine war must not make the world more reliant on fossil fuels.

He told a panel session that Europe needs to be resupplied with gas, to make up for what was lost from Russia.

But, the Ukraine crisis isn’t an excuse to build more of the old energy infrastructure, Kerry insists:

We have to be much smarter than that given the stakes.”

Fatih Birol, executive director of the International Energy Agency, also appeared on the panel, and said Russia’s invasion of Ukraine had led to a major energy crisis.

Birol said:

In my view this is the first global energy crisis.

Birol compared it to the oil crisis in 1970s, saying this time we have major problems in terms of oil, and also natural gas and coal.

Kerry argues that the world must make rapid investment in renewable energy technologies, to help the world hit the Paris Agreement goal of limiting global warming to 1.5 degrees.

Kerry says it’s possible to achieve climate goals while still also meeting the challenge of the Ukraine war:

“If we make the right choices here we can win all of these battles: we can do what we need to do with respect to Ukraine, we can do what we need to do with respect to the climate crisis.

“We cannot be seduced into believing that this suddenly is an open door to going back and doing what we were doing which created the crisis in the first place”.

Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission addresses a plenary session during the 51st annual meeting of the World Economic Forum.
Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission addresses a plenary session during the 51st annual meeting of the World Economic Forum. Photograph: Laurent Gilliéron/EPA

Full details: von der Leyen says Russia using hunger and grain to blackmail

European Commission Ursula von der Leyen told the World Economic Forum that Russia was “using hunger and grain to wield power” and blackmail other countries.

Von der Leyen said that there were obvious signs of a global food crisis, with Russia’s weaponisation of its energy supplies now being repeated in food security.

In a special address, she told Davos:

“In Russian-occupied Ukraine, the Kremlin’s army is confiscating grain stocks and machinery. For some, this has brought back memories from a dark past – the times of the Soviet crop seizures and the devastating famine of the 1930s,”

“Today, Russia’s artillery is bombarding grain warehouses across Ukraine – deliberately. And Russian warships in the Black Sea are blockading Ukrainian ships full of wheat and sunflower seeds.”

She explained there are now 20 million tonnes of wheat stuck in Ukraine. That has created a shortage that has sent global wheat prices rocketing, and meant food shipments from Odessa could not reach Somalia.

She explained that Europe was opening solidarity lanes, linking Ukraine’s borders to its ports, stepping up its own production, and working with the World Food Programme to get supplies to vulnerable countries.

“Global cooperation is the antidote to Russia’s blackmail.”

Here are video clips of Jens Stoltenberg’s speech here at Davos, via FRANCE 24:

Nato's Stoltenberg: Freedom is more important than free trade

Jens Stoltenberg, secretary general of Nato, has warned leaders at Davos of the security risks of dealing with China, as well as Russia - in a stern reminder that protecting values is more important than profits.

In a special address, Stoltenberg says countries should not trade long-term security needs for short-term economic interests.

The war in Ukraine demonstrates how economic relationships with authoratarian regimes can create vulnerabilities, he explains.

  • It creates over-reliance on key commodities such as energy
  • Sharing of technology such as artificial intelligence, which are crucial to modern weaponry, can undermine miilitary strength
  • It can create weakened resiliance from foreign control of infrastructure such as 5G mobile networks.

This is not just about Russia, it is also about China, Stoltenberg says.

International trade has undoubtedly brought great prosperity, Stoltenberg continues. But we must recognise that our economic choices have consequences for our security.

Freedom is more important than free trade.

The protection of our values is more important than profit.

He adds that he is not arguing against trade with China, but the control of 5G networks is a crucial security issue.

Stoltenberg also explains that President Putin wanted less NATO at his border. He now has more troops in Eastern Europe, and an enlarging NATO, Stoltenberg points out.

He says he’s confident that NATO will be able to welcome Finland and Sweden to the alliance.

Updated

Von der Leyen is then asked whether Russia can return to the international community.

She says it can:

Yes, if Russia finds its way back to democracy, the rule of law, the respect for the international rules-based order, then it’s a clear yes.

Russia is Europe’s neighbour, it will stay there. We have shared history and culture, she explains, adding:

It is the Russian people who decide about the future of their country. They have it in their hands.

Von der Leyen: Russia using hunder and grain to wield power

On the food crisis, Von der Leyen says Russia is using hunger and grain to wield power.

On the blockages that are causing shortages and risking famines, she says:

“In Russian-occupied Ukraine, the Kremlin’s army is confiscating grain stocks and machinery.

And Russian warships in the Black Sea are blockading Ukrainian ships full of wheat and sunflower seeds.”

Global cooperation is the antidote to this blackmail, she says, with Europe working hard to get grain to global markets.

The US is equally concerned:

Updated

Von der Leyen tells Davos that Europe is too reliant on a handful of producers for key materials, such as lithium or silicon metal.

Strong global partnerships are needed, so that Europe has more resilient supply chains, and ‘balanced interdependencies’, she says.

Von der Leyen: Could use frozen Russian assets to fund Ukraine reconstruction

Ursula von der Leyen, head of the Europen Commission, says Ukraine’s war is putting the international order into question, as she addresses the World Economic Forum’s Congress Hall.

She says Davos should be talking about making the world better together, but instead they must talk about Putin’s invasion, where Russia’s playbook for the war “comes out of another century”.

It is not just a question of Ukraine’s survival, or European security. It is putting the entire international order into question, says von der Leyen.

Ukraine must win this war. And Putin’s aggession must be a strategic failure.

Von der Leyen says Ukraine needs direct budget support now, which is why the EC proposed a $10bn package of financial assistance, its biggest ever package for a third country.

The same resolve will help Ukraine rise from the ashes, von der Leyen insists, which is the idea behind the reconstruction plan proposed to president Zelenskiy.

The work is colossal, but “together we can and will, master the challenge”.

Any country that cares about Ukraine, multinational institutions, companies. everyone, should contribute.

And Von der Leyen says that Russian assets frozen overseas could be used to fund reconstruction too:

We should leave no stone unturned, including if possible the Russian assets that we have frozen.

That massive investment should be accompanied with reforms, von der Leyen adds.

That means supporting the rule of law, and the independence of judiciary, fighting corruption, getting rid of the oligarchs, she says.

Plus, firmly supporting Ukraine in pursuing its European path.

Von der Leyen says Ukraine belongs in the European family, having stood tall in the face of brutal violance.

This is a defining moment for democracies across the globe.

Updated

Poland's president: Ukraine will not give up land in peace deal

Anyone who thinks Ukraine would give up some of its land to Russia in a peace deal is “deeply mistaken”, says Andrzej Duda, president of Poland.

Speaking here in Davos, Duda says that Ukraine would not accept such concessions, as it has suffered such losses since the Russian invasions began. Its people now want to take revenge, and to recapture their land.

I simply don’t believe they would make such concessions.

Also, any politician who accepted such concessions “would be finished”, added Duda, who addressed Ukraine’s parliament on Sunday.

He also calls for support for Ukraine, including weaponry and finance for reconstruction.

Pekka Lundberg, CEO of Nokia, says there are “worrying signs” in the economy, as the economic cycle ticks around.

But he also argues that innovations will continue, such as the industrial metaverse - where (he says) everything that makes sense to connect will be connected

Lundberg explains that

There will be a physical world, and a digital world. There will be a digital print of everthing that’s out there in the physical world.

This will mean we will know when the machines will fail.

It will mean mantainance workers will have direct digital access to that world, and will be trained to work in the digital world, before they go out to the physical world, Lundberg adds.

Spanish PM: End of history is nowhere in sight

Spain’s prime minister Pedro Sanchez said the war in Ukraine was an attack on European values, in a keynote speech to Davos.

“Liberal democracy does not come naturally and it requires considerable effort and nurturing. The end of history is nowhere in sight.”

Sanchez said the past couple of years had not been easy for the European Union.

After Brexit and Covid “we now have to deal with the consequences of a war in Ukraine.”

But Sanchez said harder times had made Europe more resolute and had strengthened the European project. The war, he concluded, was a reminder that history didn’t end when the Berlin Wall came down 30 years ago.

“The future is a land to be conquered”.

IMF chief Kristalina Georgieva is worried that the burden on developing countries (who face the brunt of the food crisis) will increase as central banks hike interest rates.

She says:

“For many countries, 2020 was the year of increased debt and that particularly applies for low-income countries where today 60% of them are either at debt distress or next to it. With high interest rates, the conditions would be very difficult.

“What we also face is significant increase of commodity prices, mostly because of the war in Ukraine. And that is terrible when it comes down to price of food for poor people and especially poor people in poor countries.

“And last but not least, we need to recognize that the Chinese economy has slowed down mostly because of lockdowns related to the pandemic. And the slowdown of growth in China has negative impact on the region and on the world.

“And that adds to the downside risks for 2022. We must stay focused on overcoming the root causes for these problems. And of course, on the top of the list is to strive for peace in Ukraine.”

South Korea will issue a call this week at the World Economic Forum for COVID-19 vaccines and other medical help for North Korea, as its Covid-19 outbreak continues.

According to a senior official, that could mean exemptions from U.N. sanctions imposed over its nuclear programme, according to a senior official.

Reuters has the details:

Secretive North Korea went for more than two years insisting it had no COVID but it confirmed its first outbreak nearly two weeks ago. It has since reported some 2.95 million people showing fever symptoms - it has limited testing capacity for COVID - and 68 deaths, and has imposed a sweeping lockdown and other anti-virus measures.

“Sending vaccines is a priority as the vaccination rate is believed to be near zero in the North,” Na Kyung-won, a special envoy of the South Korean president, told Reuters shortly before leaving for the forum in Davos, Switzerland, where she will lead South Korea’s delegation.

Na said she would discuss help for North Korea with Peter Maurer, president of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), and Seth Berkley, chief executive of Gavi, the global vaccine alliance that operates a vaccine-sharing programme, as well as other political and economic leaders.

“If direct support is not doable, we can participate in projects run by international organisations like the ICRC. We’ll take a pragmatic approach,” she said.

Na said she aimed to build support for temporary U.N. sanctions exemptions to allow the shipment of fuel and generators to North Korean to facilitate vaccine storage.

More key points from the global tax system panel:

Lagarde: Eurozone recession not base case

European Central Bank President Christine Lagarde has told Bloomberg TV in Davos that the eurozone has reached a “turning point” in monetary policy, as it prepares to leave negative interest rates behind.

Confirming her blog post yesterday, Lagarde says that the ECB is likely to exit negative interest rates by the end of the third quarter, with a first interest-rate increase set to happen in July.

Lagarde insisted that:

We not in a panic mode.

Lagarde also pushed back against the ides that the eurozone is heading into recession, saying:

“We don’t have that as a baseline.”

[the word on the floor here, though, is that Europe could be heading into recession, especially if a ban on Russian energy is agreed].

Oxfam is pushing its case for a wealth tax on billionaires, warning Davos that record-high global food prices are sparking social and political upheaval, and risk pushing millions into poverty.

Gabriela Bucher, Executive Director of Oxfam International, is speaking on a panel on reforming the global tax system.

She says one person is dying of hunger every 48 seconds in Ethiopia, Kenya and Somalia, where a drought is raging in the Horn of Africa. And

This is only the beginning, Bucher says, and the world is not raising enough money to help.

The hunger crisis is growing. We really need to move, and mobilise resources, Bucher explains, and even a small percentage increase in tax rates on millionaires would make a big difference.

Billionaires are profiting from pain, she adds, and the amounts being accumulated by the richest cannot be used in several lifetimes.

And on the global deal on minimum tax rates, Mathias Cormann, secretary general of the OECD, says he’s hopeful and optimistic Europe will implement the Pillar Two model rules (for domestic implementation of a 15% global minimum tax on multinationals).

Adam Tooze: nuclear escalation risk not priced in

Geopolitical rivalvies are also dominating attentions.

Professor Adam Tooze of Columbia University in NYC said he was worried about China, because there didn’t seem to be an “off ramp” from Beijing’s zero lockdown policy.

Tooze, though, is even more concerned about the Cold War turning hot, as the Russia-Ukraine war continues.

“The nuclear escalation risk has not been priced in” Tooze tells us, as he considered what Vladimir Putin might do next.

Politicians in the US, he said, were aiming to deprive Russia of the ability to pursue independent military action, something that it hadn’t done in the years between the end of the Second World War and the collapse of communism.

“This doesn’t feel like the Cold War”.

Tooze said he was not sure how NATO would respond to a Russian use of tactical nuclear weapons but was certain of one thing: it would lead to a monumental global financial crash.

Introduction: World 'in trouble' as food crisis intensifies

Good morning from Davos.

Worries over a worsening food crisis and an economic downturn are looming over the second day of the World Economic Forum.

The supply disruption caused by the war in Ukraine, with Black Sea ports blockaded, is driving up prices, creating shortages and the risk of famine.

Achim Steiner, the administrator of the UN Development Programme (UNDP), tells us that the world is not prepared for what’s ahead:

“We are in trouble. The war in Ukraine is dramatic in so many ways. There is an acute crisis in food, fuel and finance. As of today there is no reason to believe this is a short term challenge.

We are in the middle of a series of unfolding crises and the world is not prepared for it.

Hunger, Steiner said, was probably the one thing that got people on the streets because once people found they couldn’t afford to feed their families they lost faith in government.

“What we saw in Sri Lanka we are likely to see in more and more countries.”

Steiner said 200 million people were facing acute hunger, double the figure of five years ago. “This is very serious”, he said.

Higher energy prices - another consequence of the Ukraine war - were causing balance of payments problems for many developing countries.

“Wealthier nations have a decision to make. Are they going to step up or do they let things drift on.”

Yesterday, IMF chief Kristalina Georgieva warned that anxiety around access to food at reasonable prices is “hitting the roof” around the world.

David Beasley, head of the UN World Food Programme, warns there is a ‘devastating hunger crisis’ looming, with millions on the brink of famine.

Ursula Von Der Leyen, president of the European Commission, and Jens Stoltenberg, Secretary-General of NATO, are both giving keynote speeches today, in another busy day.

The programme’s here, and here’s a selection:

The agenda:

  • 8.45am Davos (7.45am BST): Reimagining the global tax system, with Gabriela Bucher of Oxfam, Stefanie Stantcheva, Professor of Economics at Harvard University, Mathias Cormann of the OECD
  • 10am Davos (9am BST): Special address by Spanish PM Pedro Sanchez
  • 10.45am Davos (9.45am BST): The geopolitical outlook, with Hina Rabbani Khar, Pakistan’s Minister of State for Foreign Affairs, Andrzej Duda, President of Poland, Gregory W. Meeks, Congressman from New York, José Manuel Albares Bueno, Minister of Foreign Affairs for Spain, H.H. Prince Faisal bin Farhan Al Saud, Minister of Foreign Affairs ofSaudi Arabia, Pekka Haavisto, Minister for Foreign Affairs of Finland
  • 11am Davos (10am BST): Special address by Ursula Von Der Leyen, president of the European Commission
  • 11.15am Davos (10.15am BST): Panel on Hybrid working, what happens next?
  • 11.30am Davos: Special Address by Jens Stoltenberg, Secretary-General of NATO
  • 11.45am Davos (10.45am BST): Speeding up road to net zero with Fatih Birol of IEA, John Kerry, Catherine MacGregor, Frans Timmermans.
  • 2.30pm Davos (1.30pm BST): How to tackle the cost of living crisis
  • 3pm Davos (2pm BST): Energy Security and the European Green Deal, including Pedro Sánchez, Anna Borg, CEO Vattenfall, Frans Timmermans, executive Vice-President for the European Green Deal, European Commission, Ester Baiget, CEO Novozymes, Gitanas Nausėda, President of Lithuania
  • 3.30pm Davos (2.30pm BST): A Conversation with Satya Nadella, CEO of Microsoft
  • 4.30pm Davos (3.30pm BST): Securing Europe, with Andriy Yermak, Head of the Presidential Administration of Ukraine, Belgium’s prime minister Alexander De Croo, Prime Minister of Belgium, Stevo Pendarovski, President of North Macedonia, Kajsa Ollongren, Minister of Defence of the Netherlands, Jens Stoltenberg Secretary-General of NATO
  • 5.30pm Davos (4.30pm BST): Preparing for next pandemic, including Bill Gates, Peter Sands, executive director of The Global Fund To Fight Aids, Tuberculosis & Malaria, Francis deSouza, CEO of Illumina, Helen E. Clark of WHO, Paul Kagame, President of Rwanda

Updated

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Melania and RFK Jr join forces to try to improve Trump’s diet: ‘Think fewer Big Macs and less KFC’
Incoming first lady and Trump’s pick for Health and Human Services secretary are apparently lobbying the president to make healthier choices
The Independent UK
The Independent UK
What are ‘Pink tote lid moments’? Dark TikTok trend explained
The dark trend has seen both young people and adults sharing troubling stories
The Independent UK
The Independent UK
Cruel Intentions review – this generic remake of the 90s classic is utterly mindless
Sarah Michelle Gellar and Ryan Phillippe’s movie gets a melodramatic YA remake – with a pair of actors who aren’t a patch on the originals. Just dig out the original instead
The Guardian - UK
The Guardian - UK
US moves to list giraffes under Endangered Species Act for first time
Climate crisis, habitat loss and poaching have reduced its numbers – but will Trump put the kibosh on protections?
The Guardian - US
The Guardian - US
“Who’s The One Actor That You Hate But Everyone Else Seems To Love?” (50 Answers)
No matter how popular they are, most celebrities have haters, too. Actors are no exception. The post “Who’s The One Actor That You Hate But Everyone Else Seems To Love?” (50 Answers) first appeared on Bored Panda.
Bored Panda
Bored Panda
Cher Reveals the "Fiasco" That Ensued When She Performed for Princess Margaret in 1965: "I Was Mortified"
"It was like a bad dream that we couldn’t get out of; we just had to stand there and wait for it to be over."
Marie Claire
Marie Claire
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.
Download on the AppStore Get it on Google Play