Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Top News
Top News

Controversial Conservation: Stories from the Endangered Species Act

This April 1978 photo provided via courtesy of C. Kenneth Dodd Jr. shows Glenn Clemmer, Jim Williams, center, and Royal Suttkus conducting fish surveys along the Cahaba River in Ala. (Courtesy of C. K

In the early 1970s, a wave of environmental legislation swept through the United States, aiming to protect and preserve the nation's natural resources. It was during this time that President Richard Nixon signed the Endangered Species Act into law, a powerful piece of legislation that tasked the federal government with saving every endangered plant and animal in America. The act enjoyed widespread bipartisan support and was seen as a major step towards conserving the incredible biodiversity of the country.

However, as with any sweeping legislation, controversy was bound to arise. The Endangered Species Act, while noble in its mission, did not take into consideration the economic consequences of listing species as endangered. It created a clash between the desire to preserve nature and the capitalistic ideals of private property rights. This conflict would continue to challenge the support for the act and remain unresolved to this day.

Among the group of young biologists entrusted with navigating the complexities of the Endangered Species Act were individuals like Jim Williams, an ichthyologist known as the Office of Endangered Species' first 'fish guy.' Williams had an unconventional approach and was unafraid to make bold decisions. One such decision involved listing the snail darter, a tiny fish that was only known to exist in one stretch of the Little Tennessee River, which the Tennessee Valley Authority planned to dam. Williams faced backlash and resistance from his superiors but stood his ground, believing in his mission to save species regardless of the consequences.

FILE — The snail darter is pictured in Knoxville, Tenn., on April 9, 2008. On Dec. 28, 1973, President Richard Nixon signed the Endangered Species Act. The powerful law charged the federal government with saving every endangered plant and animal in America. (Joe Howell/Knoxville News Sentinel via AP, File)
This April 1978 photo provided via courtesy of C. Kenneth Dodd Jr. shows Glenn Clemmer, Jim Williams, center, and Royal Suttkus conducting fish surveys along the Cahaba River in Ala. (Courtesy of C. Kenneth Dodd Jr. via AP)
FILE - A bald eagle surveys the water while flying over the Des Moines River, Sunday, Jan. 11, 2009, below the Lake Red Rock dam near Pella, Iowa. On Dec. 28, 1973, President Richard Nixon signed the Endangered Species Act. The powerful law charged the federal government with saving every endangered plant and animal in America. (AP Photo/Charlie Neibergall, File)
FILE - A track from a wolf is seen in the mud near the Slough Creek area of Yellowstone National Park, Wyo., Wednesday, Oct. 21, 2020. On Dec. 28, 1973, President Richard Nixon signed the Endangered Species Act. The powerful law charged the federal government with saving every endangered plant and animal in America. (AP Photo/Matthew Brown, File)
Laverne Smith, right, poses with U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Director Frank Dunkle in an undated photograph at the agency's office in Washington D.C. (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service via AP)
FILE - This March 25, 2009, file photo provided by the U.S. Geological Survey shows a polar bear in the Beaufort Sea region of Alaska. On Dec. 28, 1973, President Richard Nixon signed the Endangered Species Act. The powerful law charged the federal government with saving every endangered plant and animal in America. (Mike Lockhart/U.S. Geological Survey via AP, File)
In this 1979 photograph, Jim Williams speaks during an environmental protest against the damming of the Little Tennessee River, home of the Snail Darter, in Tenn. The fish was at the center of a battle between developers of the Tellico Dam and conservationists. (Courtesy of C. Kenneth Dodd Jr. via AP)
FILE - A California condor named Hope takes to flight at the Condor habitat at the Los Angeles Zoo, Tuesday, May 2, 2023. On Dec. 28, 1973, President Richard Nixon signed the Endangered Species Act. The powerful law charged the federal government with saving every endangered plant and animal in America. (AP Photo/Richard Vogel, File)
FILE - A herd of bison grazes during midday at a Cherokee Nation ranch in northeastern Oklahoma on Sept. 27, 2022. On Dec. 28, 1973, President Richard Nixon signed the Endangered Species Act. The powerful law charged the federal government with saving every endangered plant and animal in America. (AP Photo/Audrey Jackson, File)
In this June 1982 self portrait, C. Kenneth Dodd Jr. holds a pink Grand Canyon Rattlesnake. Dodd was participating in a survey of riparian areas along the Colorado River with the National Park Service and the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service. (Courtesy of C. Kenneth Dodd Jr. via AP)

These young biologists faced constant challenges from various stakeholders, including government officials and corporations. Ken Dodd, a herpetologist, found himself at odds with powerful entities like Purina pet food company and Monsanto. Despite threats and backlash, Dodd remained dedicated to his work and even wrote a letter to a Washington restaurant owner, urging them to find a better source for rattlesnake meat, which would violate a conservation law. This action led to Dodd being fired but garnered public attention and support, eventually leading to his reinstatement.

Ron Nowak, a biologist responsible for charismatic species like wolves and panthers, also found himself clashing with his own agency. In Minnesota, the gray wolf population was recovering thanks to the Endangered Species Act. However, the Fish and Wildlife Service wanted to open the gray wolf to public hunting as a means of population control. Nowak refused to write the regulation to support hunting, believing it to be illegal. Conservation groups sued, and Nowak testified against his own agency, ultimately succeeding in preventing the hunting of gray wolves.

LaVerne Smith, one of the Office of Endangered Species' first botanists, witnessed the program go through multiple reorganizations and challenges. She played a part in the successful recovery of the critically endangered California condor. Smith later moved to Alaska, where she led the listing for the polar bear, the first animal listed as endangered due to climate change. She acknowledges the immense challenges posed by climate change and the urgent need for quick decision-making to address the threats faced by numerous species.

Marc Imlay, a malacologist, focused on freshwater mussels, one of the most critically endangered groups of organisms in the country. He worked undercover, informing environmental organizations about endangered mussel habitats threatened by dam construction, successfully stopping several projects. Imlay acknowledges that at times, he had to work secretively to overcome bureaucratic hurdles, but his efforts often resulted in successful solutions that satisfied both developers and conservationists.

John Spinks, an early chief of the Office of Endangered Species, recognized the dedication and passion of his team of biologists. While some resorted to unconventional methods, such as leaking memos to the media, they were driven by a genuine desire to protect endangered species. Spinks understood the importance of allowing his passionate team to do their work, supporting them in their mission.

The stories of these biologists highlight the complexities and challenges faced by those working to protect endangered species. They were motivated by a deep sense of purpose and often had to navigate political and economic obstacles to achieve their conservation goals. Their efforts remind us of the importance of preserving our natural world, even in the face of adversity.

As we confront new challenges like climate change, the work of these biologists serves as inspiration. It reminds us that hope and resilience are vital in the conservation journey. The Endangered Species Act, with all its controversies and conflicts, has undeniably made a significant impact on protecting and preserving America's remarkable biodiversity. And while the battles continue, it is crucial to remember that the ultimate goal is to ensure a thriving and harmonious coexistence between humans and the incredible array of life with which our country has been blessed.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.