For anybody growing up in the aughts, Chad Michael Murray was the epitome of a teenage dream. Known best for navigating some complicated family dynamics on and off the basketball court as Lucas Scott on One Tree Hill, Murray actually played a few different heartthrobs before becoming a familiar face to Hallmark Christmas Movie fans. Certainly everybody’s got a favorite, but what does the actor think? Murray recently played a game of Kiss, Marry, Kill with a few of his most famous roles, and let’s just say things didn’t go so well for his Gilmore Girls character.
During an interview with the Canadian network CTV, Chad Michael Murray was asked to kiss, marry and kill one of his 2000s-era characters, choosing between Lucas Scott (of course), Tristan Dugray from Gilmore Girls and Austin Ames from A Cinderella Story. He started off with the first option, saying:
