In 'Your Monster,' writer-director Caroline Lindy takes audiences on a journey of empowerment, albeit with a clumsy metaphor. The film centers around Laura Franco, a talented young actor played by Melissa Barrera, whose Broadway dreams are shattered when she receives a cancer diagnosis. However, her life takes an unexpected turn when she encounters a beastly creature lurking in her childhood home. This creature, portrayed by Tommy Dewey, begins as a surly roommate, evolves into a potential love interest, and ultimately becomes a manifestation of Laura's suppressed rage.
While 'Your Monster' may not fit the conventional horror genre, it follows in the footsteps of films like 'Colossal' and 'A Monster Calls' by blending genres and delivering a unique narrative experience. Set in the dramatic world of musical theater, the film explores themes of resilience and self-discovery. Yet, its symbolism is far from subtle, as Laura learns to break free from societal expectations and embrace her hidden emotions.
Caroline Lindy's script openly declares its cinematic goals as Laura tearfully watches Stanley Donen's 'Royal Wedding,' a classic romance. However, 'Your Monster' diverges from this archetype and leans more towards a grudge match. Lindy herself drew inspiration from her personal experiences, having been dumped by an insensitive boyfriend during her own cancer treatment. While Laura's breakup may evoke sympathy, Barrera's portrayal of the character as pouty and privileged may make it difficult for audiences to connect with her.
Flashbacks reveal Laura's aspirations of starring in a musical called 'The House of Good Women,' which she collaborated on with her ex-boyfriend, Jacob. However, the film fails to provide evidence of Laura's talent, relying on cliched montages and moments of emotional breakdown rather than deeply exploring her character. Barrera's performance leaves much to be desired, and it becomes hard to believe that her character belongs on a professional stage.
Lindy treats 'Your Monster' like a high-concept sitcom premise, relying on hammy montages and cringe-inducing moments. The film lacks the necessary comedic moments to fully engage the audience. Laura's audition for Jacob's musical turns into a disaster, setting up the predictable path of her becoming the understudy after her ex offers her the role out of sympathy. The story becomes frustratingly obvious as Laura musters the courage to unleash her rage, though the presentation of her monster as a grouchy companion rather than a full transformation lacks satisfying impact.
Dewey's portrayal of the adorable-ogre creature may entertain younger audiences with his millennial lingo and modern references. However, the film leaves much to be desired, despite the energetic performance brought by Kayla Foster as Laura's friend, Mazie. The film's overall tone leans towards mopey, missing opportunities for a more impactful ending.
Ultimately, 'Your Monster' serves as an intermittently amusing yet grubby-looking pity party. While Laura's struggles and emotional journey may warrant empathy, the film fails to elicit a strong emotional response. It lacks the necessary depth to truly captivate and connect with its audience. In the end, Laura can cry if she wants to, but 'Your Monster' doesn't quite manage to make us shed a tear.
