Welcome to the BANI world—Brittle, Anxious, Nonlinear, and Incomprehensible. This new paradigm has replaced the familiar VUCA (Volatile, Uncertain, Complex, Ambiguous) framework. The shift from VUCA to BANI is evident in three key areas. First, the speed of change has accelerated dramatically. While VUCA acknowledged constant change, BANI recognizes the increased velocity of change. Second, BANI acknowledges the complexity created by the interconnectedness of our global systems. In a deeply intertwined world, risks are nonlinear and contagious in ways that are often unpredictable. Finally, the emotional impact of change has intensified. BANI highlights the widespread anxiety and polarization of our era, in which responses can accelerate crises.
In September 2024, Tupperware Brands, once a symbol of American ingenuity and household organization, filed for bankruptcy protection. The collapse of this iconic brand, which had thrived for more than 70 years, is a fundamental reminder of how quickly established businesses can crumble in today’s precarious environment. Amongst the reasons Tupperware cited for its decline include the challenging macroeconomic environment and changing customer preferences. However, the company’s continued reliance on a direct sales model that had been effective in the 20th century instead of developing an e-commerce strategy and infrastructure was its fatal flaw.
On the other hand, Advanced Micro Devices (AMD), once on the brink of extinction, underwent a remarkable change under Lisa Su's leadership. AMD made bold strategic moves to reposition itself and benefit from the industry’s growth: Competitive pricing, improved performance, more comprehensive open-source firmware support, and better compatibility expanded its market share, taking AMD from near bankruptcy to major player in the computer business in a decade. In addition, big bets on AI PCs have positioned the company to compete with Nvidia and Intel in attracting new customers seeking a single-vendor solution.
Success in the BANI world demands a top-to-bottom transformation of corporate leadership and governance. A crucial element of this transformation is the need for Boards, CEOs, and C-Suite executives to reassess the composition and responsibilities of their respective roles. We propose a five-part framework for this radical shift.
- Redefining the Board: To provide effective oversight, Boards must recognize the value of every seat at the table. Successfully navigating complex, nonlinear challenges requires a broader definition of diversity to include experiential and cognitive diversity and the goal of true inclusion. Term limits, performance evaluations, and commitment to continuous learning are fundamental to the Board’s ability to stay ahead of rapid changes. And a BANI world requires oversight of corporate strategy to evolve from an annual exercise to a standing agenda item at meetings that include internal and external experts as needed.
- The New CEO: The ideal CEO profile has changed dramatically in the BANI world. Adaptive leadership – the ability to navigate constant change and ambiguity with agility and resilience – is now paramount. This adaptability must be coupled with technological fluency, not just a surface-level understanding of tech trends, but the ability to leverage that knowledge strategically to drive business growth and innovation. Moreover, the modern CEO must excel in stakeholder management, skillfully balancing the often-conflicting demands of shareholders, employees, customers, and regulators.
- Reimagining the C-Suite: The C-suite, once a collection of siloed experts, must be reimagined as a collaborative, cross-functional team to drive agility and innovation. This change requires a focus on cross-pollination of ideas, encouraging executives to work outside their traditional domains and bringing fresh perspectives to challenges. Rapid experimentation should be at the core of C-suite operations, fostering a culture of iterative learning that can keep pace with the nonlinear nature of the BANI world. In addition, data-driven decision-making must become the norm, leveraging AI and analytics for real-time insights.
- AI Integration: Artificial Intelligence represents a fundamental reshaping of how businesses operate. Organizations should approach AI integration strategically, beginning with efficiency and experience enhancements, then leveraging AI for customer loyalty and expansion, and finally exploring AI-driven opportunities in adjacent markets and new business models.
- Measuring Success: In tandem with AI integration, organizations must redefine their performance metrics for the BANI world taking a more holistic approach that focuses on long-term value creation through three-to-five-year Total Shareholder Return (TSR) rather than quarterly results. This approach should be complemented by stakeholder capitalism, measuring impact across all stakeholders, not just shareholders. Adaptive performance monitoring, with flexible KPIs that can evolve with changing circumstances, is crucial in navigating the nonlinear aspects of the BANI environment.
The BANI world doesn't allow for piecemeal changes or drawn-out decision-making. Organizations need a bold approach that touches every aspect of governance and leadership. This includes a clear-eyed assessment of BANI readiness, reimagining board composition and processes, developing new criteria for selecting and evaluating top leaders, fostering a culture of adaptive innovation, creating a comprehensive AI roadmap, redefining success metrics, and adopting proactive, transparent stakeholder communication.
The challenges of the BANI world are formidable—but so are the opportunities. Organizations that recognize this new reality and embrace comprehensive change will be best positioned to thrive. The choice is clear: adapt holistically or risk becoming another cautionary tale. The time for incremental change has passed. For Boards, CEOs, and C-Suites, it’s now or never.
More must-read commentary published by Fortune:
- Former Intel CEO Craig Barrett: Splitting up America’s leading chipmaker is a bad idea
- We led some of America’s largest companies. Here’s why we are voting for Harris, not Trump
- How the Democrat-leaning news media is unwittingly aiding Trump
- As activist Starboard engages constructively, here’s a potent prescription for Pfizer’s future success under Dr. Bourla’s watch
The opinions expressed in Fortune.com commentary pieces are solely the views of their authors and do not necessarily reflect the opinions and beliefs of Fortune.
