Michael Rorrer, a 31-year-old Oxnard, California, resident, discovered 345 comics in a basement closet in his late great-aunt's Martinsville, Virginia, home in 2011, a collection quietly assembled decades earlier by his great-uncle Billy Wright. According to the Associated Press, Wright, who died in 1994 at age 66, collected the comics as a boy and young man between 1936 and 1941, later becoming a chemical engineer, and never discussed the collection with relatives beyond one brief mention. Heritage Auctions described the find as one of the most important Golden Age comic book collections in decades. Heritage Auctions reported in February 2012 that 44 of the 345 comics in Wright's collection ranked among the top 100 Golden Age comics in the Overstreet Comic Book Price Guide, a detail the Associated Press also cited in its coverage of the auction. That concentration of high-value issues is part of what convinced buyers and experts of the collection's authenticity.
Get breaking news anytime, anywhere. Download the TOI app now!
Paper quality from that era makes surviving copies unusually fragile
Comics from this era were printed on cheap, highly acidic wood-pulp newsprint, since publishers considered them disposable at the time. Research published in Polymer Degradation and Stability has shown that volatile organic compounds emitted by paper and archival materials continue to degrade them even in protective storage, which helps explain why so few Golden Age comics survive in good condition.
Detective Comics No. 27 led the sale at $522,813
As per AP (23 Feb., 2012) via Hurriyet Daily News, Heritage Auctions' sale of Billy Wright's Detective Comics #27 for nearly $523,000 is the highest selling price of this item in the New York auction of February 2012. In this regard, the first issue of Superman from the year 1938 called Action Comics No. 1 fetched a price of $298,750. Heritage Auctions (Feb. 2012) said Billy Wright’s copy of Batman #1 sold for $274,850 at the New York auction.
The Antique Trader (February 18, 2025) reports that a Near Mint copy of Captain America Comics #2 (Timely, 1941) sold through Heritage Auctions for $113,500. This was close to the $113,525 that Wright's own copy of the same issue fetched at the original 2012 sale. A 2012 hedonic pricing study in the Journal of Cultural Economics , based on 1,100 American collectible comic books, found that a comic's condition, rarity, and documented ownership history each measurably affect its sale price, separate from the story or character inside; one reason collections with a clear, verified history like Wright's tend to command strong prices.
The total sale brought in about $3.5 million
Associated Press (Feb. 2012) stated that the Billy Wright comic book collection found by Michael Rorrer was auctioned off for around $3.5 million at Heritage Auctions' February 2012 auction, with the money split between Rorrer, his brother Jonathan, and his mother Lisa Hernandez. According to Lon Allen, the managing director of comic books at Heritage Auctions, this was a type of Golden Age comic book collection that everybody thought did not exist anymore.
