Fans of college football fanbases love to debate, especially when it comes to naming their favorite program (insert position) U.
Ohio State often gets inserted deeply into the debate because of all the talent it sends to the NFL, but so do many other programs. And when it comes to the Big Ten, the Buckeyes aren’t the only program that excels at individual positions.
ESPN ran a piece examining and researching which schools produced the best talent at each position, and as you would expect, Ohio State was well represented. But how do the Buckeyes line up with their Big Ten brethren? If we were to name a Big Ten school as the best at developing talent at each position group, which schools would come out on top for quarterbacks, running backs, defensive backs, etc.? I mean, you get the idea.
We decided to name a school as position U for each of the spots on the football field based on the research and numbers ESPN published to declare supremacy in the Big Ten.
Off we go. Get in the act and tell us where you might disagree with ESPN’s assessment.
NEXT … How it all works
How it all works
The method to the madness according to ESPN
“We’re counting players since 1998 only. Why 1998? It seemed a good breaking point, as it was the start of the BCS era that best represents modern college football. We know Notre Dame would love to claim Paul Hornung in the race for, um, Halfback U, but we’re trying to keep it to the era of players today’s recruits might be most familiar with.
“What counts as success? We narrowed it down to a few key categories. Schools got points for all-conference and All-America selections, along with points for being drafted (weighted by round) and for success at the next level. For that last category, we looked at only the first four years of a player’s career (beyond that, the NFL should get credit for development) using Pro Football Reference’s weighted career value.
“Dealing with transfers is tricky, too. When Jordan Addison gets drafted next year, will he count for Pitt or USC? Sorry to add some more salt to the wounds for Panthers fans, but we’ve made the call that NFL data counts only toward the school a player last suited up for.”
Quarterback U of the Big Ten
The Big Ten’s Quarterback U?
Ohio State
Breaking it Down
Many fans will point to the lack of success at the NFL level for OSU quarterbacks, and that’s fair. However — remember — this is about producing guys under center and nobody in the Big Ten has done it better than Ohio State recently. There have been multiple conference Players of the Year, a few Heisman finalists, and multiple records set in Columbus. Troy Smith, Terrelle Pryor, Braxton Miller, J.T. Barrett, Justin Fields, Dwayne Haskins, and now C.J. Stroud. The list goes on and on.
Running Back U of the Big Ten
The Big Ten’s Running Back U?
Breaking it Down
This is a slam dunk. Wisconsin went to a culture of physicality and keeping things on the ground when Barry Alvarez took over and has been off and running since. No Big Ten school has had the number of high-level running backs as the Badgers. Ron Dayne, Melvin Gordon, and Jonathan Taylor are just a few examples of some of the all-time great backs in the conference.
Wide Receiver U of the Big Ten
The Big Ten’s Wide Receiver U?
Ohio State
Breaking it Down
The Buckeyes are quickly becoming Wide Receiver U in the country with the number of high-profile recruits and coaching at that position, but historically speaking, for a program that used to go by the “three yards and a cloud of dust” way of winning, there have been some electric athletes catching passes, even before Ryan Day arrived on campus. Heck, Ohio State had two receivers go in the first round of the NFL draft this year and still look to be almost just as dangerous in the air this fall.
Tight End U of the Big Ten
The Big Ten’s Tight End U?
Breaking it Down
Iowa’s Sam LaPorta might be the best tight end in the Big Ten this fall, but that’s just the latest good one the Hawkeyes have churned out. Kirk Ferentz uses an offensive system that’s very tight end friendly, and it’s resulted in a lot of good ones coming to the program and then being developed. Dallas Clark anyone?
Offensive Line U of the Big Ten
The Big Ten’s Offensive Line U?
Wisconsin
Breaking it Down
I mean, if you’re going to run the ball, you better have a way of getting guys to produce on the offensive line, and that’s exactly what Wisconsin has done over the years. Seemingly every year, the Badgers have a high-profile offensive lineman looking to hear his name called in the NFL draft. Ohio State is a close second, but there’s really no argument to flip the two.
Defensive Line U
The Big Ten’s Defensive Line U?
Ohio State
Breaking it Down
Penn State has a bit of an argument here, but ever since the Nittany Lions let Larry Johnson get away, he’s been recruiting and developing guys like the Bosa brothers and Chase Young. There always seems to be high production coming from the defensive line at Ohio State, and that’s because of the players being produced yearly now.
Linebacker U of the Big Ten
The Big Ten’s Linebacker U?
Ohio State
Breaking it Down
Though there’s been a slide in production the last couple of years, Ohio State can lay claim to being Linebacker U. All-Americans like James Laurinaitis, A.J. Hawk, and Ryan Shazier have been running down ball carriers and filling holes with the best of them. Sorry, Penn State, but you just aren’t Linebacker U any longer.
Defensive Back U of the Big Ten
The Big Ten’s Defensive Back U?
Ohio State
Breaking it Down
ESPN actually named Ohio State DBU in all of college football. It won’t settle the hot debate between OSU, LSU, Florida State, and Alabama among others, but it’s nice to be noticed. The Buckeyes have produced a whopping 31 All-Big Ten defensive backs since 1998, many of which have gone on to play in the NFL at a high level. Marshon Lattimore, Denzel Ward, and others are still making their names at the highest level today.
Kicker U of the Big Ten
The Big Ten’s Kicker U?
Iowa
Breaking it Down
Ohio State is a close second, but Iowa takes the crown. Because of the ball-control offense head coach Kirk Ferentz employs, the kicker gets a lot of opportunities at kicking the ball through the uprights. There have been a lot of good ones, but Nate Kaeding might be the best of them all.
The Big Ten’s Kicker U?
Iowa
Breaking it Down
The Breakdown
Summarizing and breaking it all down
Quarterback U – Ohio State
Running Back U – Wisconsin
Wide Receiver U – Ohio State
Tight End U – Iowa
Offensive Line U – Wisconsin
Defensive Line U – Ohio State
Linebacker U – Ohio State
Defensive Back U – Ohio State
Kicker U – Iowa
Contact/Follow us @BuckeyesWire on Twitter, and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Ohio State news, notes, and opinion. Follow Phil Harrison on Twitter.
Let us know your thoughts, and comment on this story below. Join the conversation today.
