Here we're looking at the Beautyrest Harmony Lux vs Cloverland Hybrid mattress to see how they compare in key areas such as comfort, temperature regulation, motion isolation and pressure relief. We'll also look at whether either is a good alternative to the Saatva Classic, a luxury innerspring hybrid and our top recommendation for this year's best mattress for all sleepers.
Both the Beautyrest Harmony Lux and the Cloverlane Hybrid mattress are made from a combination of memory foam and coils, and both deliver enhanced back support similar to the Saatva Classic. Price-wise there's less than $300 between them for a queen size, with a queen Beautyrest costing $1,399 compared to $1,696 (was $2,095) for a queen Cloverlane Hybrid.
Let's take a closer look at these luxury mattresses now, to see which one is the right fit for your sleep. To learn more about the Saatva, read our Saatva Classic mattress review to see how we slept on it.
Beautyrest Harmony Lux vs Cloverlane Hybrid mattress: Specs
Each of these mattresses have specific factors to recommend them, and to some degree they share similarities in terms of customization options and cooling. Here's how they compare in terms of spec:
Beautyrest Harmony Lux vs Cloverlane Hybrid mattress: Price & trial
- Beautyrest tends to discount around major holidays, with up to $200 off
- The Cloverlane Hybrid is 50% off every month
- Cloverlane offers a longer trial at 365-nights vs 100 nights at Beautyrest
Beautyrest tends to concentrate its discounts around major sales events, although it’s worth bookmarking our mattress sales page to keep up with the latest offers. There’s also quite a large difference in price depending on which series of mattress you buy (more on that later), along with the firmness option you choose.
A queen Harmony Lux mattress starts from $1,399 at full MSRP, although this price rises up to a maximum of $2,199 if you need something bigger. Sales normally knock around $200 off the MSRP – the mattress is full price as we write, but you can get two pillows for 50% off if you buy them with the mattress and enter the code PILLOW50 at checkout.
The Cloverlane Hybrid, on the other hand, has been on offer since its launch. Initially the discount knocked $700 off all sizes, but this has now risen to 50% off, giving a massive $800 off all sizes. This means you can pick up a queen for $1,399 as opposed to the MSRP of $2,199. There's also a reduced price bedding bundle available if you buy this alongside the mattress.
Both the Beautyrest and the Cloverlane are $300 cheaper than the Saatva Classic, so you will save money by choosing one of them. Like the Classic, the Cloverlane comes with a 365-night trial, lifetime warranty and free white glove delivery. The Beautyrest falls down a little here – yes, you’ll get free white glove delivery, but there’s only a 100-night trial and 10-year warranty on offer.
Beautyrest Harmony Lux vs Cloverlane Hybrid mattress: Materials & design
- The Beautyrest has four firmness options, a choice of pillow tops and heights
- The Cloverlane has three firmness options, but only one height
- Both are hybrids, but the Beautyrest is an innerspring hybrid
The Beautyrest Harmony Lux’s options are, quite frankly, overly complicated. As already mentioned, there are two series to choose from: the Premier Anchor Island series is available with a plush or firm firmness, or you can choose to add a plush or medium pillow top to soften the feel; the Exceptional Coral Island series comes with a choice of medium or extra firm firmness ratings, with the choice of adding either a plush or firm pillow top.
Beautyrest mattresses have variable heights across the selection, with these ranging between 12.5” and 15”. They start with a quilted soft foam cover, covered with Seaqual sustainable fabric that’s made of recycled plastic waste. Up next are layers of foam.
There’s a layer of the brand’s proprietary InfiniCool Lux foam for response to pressure, AirFeel memory foam to contour to the body, and RightTemp Wave foam with carbon fibers for increased breathability. The mattress sits on a layer of individually wrapped pocket coils surrounded by high-density foam for extra edge support.
The Cloverlane Hybrid is available in three firmness options, like the Saatva Classic. Recently the brand, perhaps in an attempt to distance its mattress from the Saatva, has renamed the three options. You can now get a Plush Soft (4/10), Medium (5-7/10) or Luxury Firm (8/10) option, depending on your preference.
The cover on the Cloverlane is made from polyester, cotton and polyethylene and designed to be breathable and cooling. It’s not removable though, so make sure you invest in a decent mattress protector to keep it clean. Inside this is the 1.75” plush foam Euro top with zoned quilting, followed by a layer of gel-infused memory foam for adaptive support.
Underneath this is a layer of latex for spinal alignment, followed by a layer of transition foam that sits on top of the individually wrapped coil support system. These are surrounded by a dense wall of foam for edge support. And, at the bottom of the mattress, you’ll find a shift-resistant bottom cover with eight handles for easy moving, and 16 brass air vents for more airflow.
Beautyrest Harmony Lux vs Cloverlane Hybrid mattress: Comfort & support
- The Beautyrest Harmony Lux is available in four firmness levels
- The Cloverlane Hybrid is also available in three firmness levels
- Both will suit a variety of sleep styles due to the custom options
As previously mentioned, the Beautyrest has a somewhat baffling number of options. What this does mean, however, is that you should be able to find an option to suit your sleeping style. Across the two series you’ll find options for Plush, Medium, Firm and Extra Firm, plus the option to add in a plush, medium or firm pillow top.
In our Beautyrest Harmony Lux mattress review, we tested the Coral Island series in a Firm Pillow Top and found it more than lived up to its advertised firmness, offering more of a ‘lying on top’ feel to the mattress, rather than any sinkage. It was particularly comfortable for front and larger build back sleepers, as you would expect and offers a similar feel to the best firm mattresses on the market.
The Harmony Lux is also firmer than any of the Saatva Classic mattresses, which means it could be a good option for those with heavier builds. With a range of other firmness options available, you can also choose a softer mattress if you’re a side sleeper, or a medium mattress for light and average back sleepers. Pressure relief is also excellent, particularly with the slightly softer mattresses.
In our Cloverlane Hybrid mattress review, our tester slept on the Plush Soft mattress for four weeks. Despite the brand rating the mattress at 4/10, our tester felt it was nearer to 7/10 for the first few weeks, eventually softening up a little over time. It’s certainly far firmer than the equivalent Saatva Classic, which is a true Plush Soft.
However, all our testers were comfortable on the mattress and side sleepers in particular felt their pressure points were supported and cushioned. Our lead tester also rated the latex lumbar strip for relieving their back pain, feeling it relieved pressure extremely successfully.
This is a good mattress for back pain, and is endorsed by the American Chiropractic Association (the Saatva is endorsed by the Congress of Chiropractic State Associations, so also an excellent choice for back pain).
Beautyrest Harmony Lux vs Cloverlane Hybrid mattress: Temperature control
- Beautyrest’s RightTemp foam is designed to dissipate heat
- The Cloverlane has perforated latex and brass vents for cooling
- As hybrids, both use coils, around which air flows better
Beautyrest’s mattresses employ a few special foams to keep sleepers cool, and the Harmony Lux is no exception. The RightTemp layer contains conductive carbon fibers for increased breathability, and there’s also an InfiniCool MAX plant-based layer containing cooling foam and surface cooling fibers. The cover is breathable, and coils help to promote airflow. Beyond all the fancy names, the mattress actually does a great job of heat dispersal and kept our sleepers comfortable throughout the night.
The Cloverlane Hybrid is designed for cooler sleep with individually wrapped springs to encourage airflow and 16 hand-installed brass vents at the base for heat to escape. The latex layer is also perforated to encourage even more airflow. There’s also a breathable cover made of a cotton and polyester blend. It’s not a profoundly cooling mattress, but our testers found it comfortable and a step above many other memory foam hybrids.
Of course, neither mattress is a specialist cooling mattress. If you’re a particularly hot sleeper, consider one of our best cooling mattresses to keep you comfy at night.
Beautyrest Harmony Lux vs Cloverlane Hybrid mattress: Which should you buy?
Buy the Beautyrest Harmony Lux mattress if…
✅ You sleep hot: The Beautyrest feels cool to the touch and contains plenty of features to help keep sleepers cool through the night. It’s not a cooling mattress, but for most sleepers with a tendency to sleep hot it should be cool enough to keep them comfortable.
✅ You want lots of customization options: With the many options available with this mattress, sleepers can really tweak it to meet their exact sleeping specifications. This does require taking the time to understand all the options though.
✅ You want decent edge support: We found the Beautyrest extremely supportive around the edges, meaning sleepers can make use of the full width of the mattress.
Buy the Cloverlane Hybrid mattress if…
✅ You want to spend less: We’re not suggesting that the Cloverlane is a cheap mattress (it’s not), but with the generous discounts available you will pay a decent amount less than you would for most incarnations of the Beautyrest. It’s also cheaper than the Saatva Classic.
✅ You want more of a ‘sink in’ feeling: The Cloverlane has more sinkage than the Beautyrest and there’s also the option to go for the all-foam version if you want the deep pressure relief and excellent motion isolation that foam provides.
✅ You suffer from back pain: Endorsed by the American Chiropractic Association, the Cloverlane is a great choice if you suffer from back pain, offering excellent support in the lumbar region.
