Time to sign off – I’ll leave you with Ben Fisher’s report from another weird and wild night of Barclays. Goodnight, and happy Christmas if you’re celebrating.
Chris Wilder: “I’ve got mixed feelings! Delighted with the result, the structure of the team. I give the players an awful lot of credit for taking on so much information. I’m still learning about a lot of these players.”
“There were a hundred VAR checks, but we got a bit more of the ball. We thought we had it – smash and grab, whatever you want to call it – but wasn’t to be. We weren’t here to be cannon fodder, we said ‘break us down’. I’m not ashamed of that, they had won 15 in a row.”
I felt that bringing Wilder, who succeeded here before with a particular system and group of players, back in the middle of a relegation dogfight was a bit of a desperate move. But he has already made Sheffield United a much tougher proposition. Next up: Luton (H), Manchester City (A).
Some reaction from Sheffield United’s Cameron Archer and Wes Foderingham. The keeper says he’s “bitterly disappointed” at the late equaliser, while Archer blames “concentration” for the three points slipping away, but adds that the result is “something to build on”.
“The manager’s been clear about how he wants to play, and we’re taking it on board,” adds Fotheringham. “We’re trying to make ourselves hard to beat. On the disallowed Bailey goal, he says “both hands” were pulling him down. Archer says the result is “something to build on.”
“Bitter Villa fan here,” writes David Cameron Bertram. “Sheffield United have played very well. I don’t follow why the goal was chalked off and the penalties not given. But also we didn’t turn up.” A fair summary, although I hope the equaliser at least cheered you up a bit.
“Finished 0-0 at a nearly deserted Hampden,” reports Simon McMahon. “I think Queen’s Park v Aston Villa (in 1885) would have been a better game.” Still, it’s a fun, quirky fixture to cross off your ground-hopping list eh, Simon? … Simon?
Auston Trusty, who was booked for dissent after the goal, continues to complain after the final whistle. I think it’s over an incident near the halfway line where a Sheffield United player went down rather cheaply, before the move that led to Zaniolo scoring.
Villa could have had a penalty and saw Leon Bailey’s goal controversially disallowed, so the visitors can’t feel too hard done by. Oddly, they look the more disappointed with a result they would have gladly taken before kick off.
Updated
Full time! Aston Villa 1-1 Sheffield United
Cameron Archer’s late goal rocked Villa Park but Nicolò Zaniolo’s header deep in stoppage time allowed the hosts to rescue something. Still, the winning streak comes to an end, and the chance to go top has been missed on a frustrating night.
Updated
99 mins: McAtee tries to get a late shot away but is crowded out – and there’s the final whistle.
98 mins: Villa want another, and Cash’s cross causes panic before Foderingham punches away. McAtee then motors downfield, and Cash has to bring him down. He’s booked, and will miss the Boxing Day trip to Old Trafford.
For the 100th time, Villa try a chipped cross into the danger area – but this time it works, as Zaniolo gets in ahead of Fotheringham and flicks the ball into the net!
GOAL! Aston Villa 1-1 Sheffield United (Zaniolo 97')
Nicolò Zaniolo has grabbed a late leveller!
Updated
96 mins: Ramsey drifts out to the left and his cross is cleared behind by Norwood. Villa line up for the corner … but it’s cleared at the near post.
94 mins: Cash seeks out Watkins with another cross from deep, but it’s a defender who gets his head to it first. Zaniolo then goes over looking for a free kick, is told to get up, and is booked for his protests.
92 mins: More penalty box tussling, Watkins almost connecting with the ball and then going over in a heap. Anthony Taylor not interested.
90 mins: Archer is replaced by Oli McBurnie. Sheffield United have nine minutes of added time to hold on.
89 mins: Oof! The clearest opening for some time for Villa as Álex Moreno gets his head to a cross, but Foderingham pushes it away – and the corner ends up on the roof of the net, to widespread dismay.
Updated
From the free kick, Hamer did brilliantly to get beyond McGinn and keep the ball in play, and he cuts back for Archer to finish at the near post. Sheffield United might just have nicked this, and Wilder’s game plan has paid off!
GOAL!!! Aston Villa 0-1 Sheffield United (Archer 87')
A night of acute frustration for Aston Villa gets even worse – their former player has fired Sheffield United in front!
Updated
86 mins: Durán is certainly involved now, getting into an altercation with Jack Robinson, who is left with a cut after being clipped by a raised elbow. VAR rules it was accidental, and we play on …
84 mins: Villa haven’t been able to regain their attacking rhythm after making those changes, with Durán yet to really get into the game.
81 mins: Archer beats the offside trap and his shot is charged down before Norwood fires his shot wide. For the hosts, Nicolò Zaniolo replaces Bailey, who had a frustrating night all round.
80 mins: Yikes! Sheffield United go very close to taking the lead on another breakaway, as Lowe’s cross is clumsily deflected just wide by Konsa. That could have gone anywhere, and the nerves are certainly jangling inside Villa Park now – but Martínez is able to collect comfortably from the corner.
79 mins: Watkins, marshalled by Robinson and Trusty all night, gets a brief glimpse of goal but his shot lacks the power to trouble Foderingham.
78 mins: Watkins is again beaten to a long ball by Foderingham, while at the other end, Archer is offside as he threatens to break through on goal.
77 mins: Oof! Sheffield United threaten to really ruin Villa’s night here. Archer has Konsa sweating in a foot race for the ball, and then Norwood’s well-hit shot from distance is held by Emi Martínez.
76 mins: Cash picks out Bailey with a pass into the area, but his control lets him down as he tries to turn and shoot. Ben Slimane, who’s had a suitably festive silent night, is replaced by McAtee.
75 mins: Bailey offers up a textbook, 0-0-with-time-running-out, speculator from 30 yards that flies very high and just as wide.
74 mins: Amid all the slo-mo replays and crowd groans, Emery has to find a way to win this game. He brings on Jhon Durán for Diaby, and Álex Moreno to replace Digne.
72 mins: VAR returns! A cross towards Ramsey is knocked down by Baldock, and it looks like a handball on first viewing. After a review, it’s judged to have been above the “T-shirt line”, so no penalty.
70 mins: Another Villa free-kick is cleared away, the yellow wall Wilder brought in from Dortmund for the night still doing its job.
68 mins: Aside from the VAR hullabaloo, the disallowed goal was maybe the first time Villa had been able to turn this massed visiting defence and get in behind – and they scored. Can they repeat the trick?
66 mins: From a Villa corner, Hamer almost pounces on a Diaby slip as Sheffield United break – but he’s isolated upfield and the chance fizzles out.
Unai Emery is remonstrating at length with the fourth official. You can’t blame him – there are big questions about that decision, chiefly whether it was the same phase of play, and also the fact that Bogle was also involved, tussling with Ramsey.
What we’re left with is Watkins being pulled down in the area – no penalty – and then Ramsey pulling Foderingham’s arm – goal disallowed. Honestly, it doesn’t make a lot of sense.
No goal! Bailey's strike ruled out by VAR
Here’s what happened: Foderingham flapped at the corner, and replays show Ramsey had a grip on his arm. The visitors won the ball though, and had the chance to clear, but Baldock was dispossessed and Watkins crossed low for Bailey to score. Anthony Taylor goes over to the monitor, and rules the goal out for a foul!
Updated
59 mins: GOAL? Villa think they have the lead, Bailey finishing well from Watkins’ cross – but there was a foul on the keeper from the initial corner, and VAR are taking a long look …
56 mins: Larouci prods the ball behind under pressure from Diaby – and that’s the end of his night, with Lowe replacing him. Gustavo Hamer is the mystery man, coming on for Andre Brooks in midfield.
55 mins: Wilder is preparing a couple of substitutes to come on – one is Max Lowe, the other a mystery at time of writing.
54 mins: Cash and Bailey combine effectively down the right again, and the right-back chips a cross in that’s just over Ramsey’s head.
52 mins: Villa have definitely eased off the throttle a touch, playing up to the final third and then waiting for an opening. McGinn looks for Digne with a cross that Bogle heads away, before Diaby and Watkins almost link up on the edge of the area.
50 mins: Larouci had bought himself some hand with Bailey getting booked, but he quickly surrenders it by barging into his opponent, and getting a yellow card of his own.
49 mins: The free kick finds Robinson in unexpected space, and he opts to cross rather than shoot – but the flag is up, Villa’s hair-trigger offside trap doing the job.
48 mins: Larouci barrels upfield and Bailey pulls him back, grabs his shirt and then bundles him over. It’s once, twice, three times a yellow for Bailey – the first of the match.
47 mins: Villa start off patiently, trying to find gaps down the right and then the left, where the advancing Digne wins a corner. From Cash’s cross, Watkins’ back-post corner causes trouble but Sheffield United scramble it away.
Here we go again
An intriguing stat for you: in 93 matches, Unai Emery has never overseen a goalless draw in the Premier League.
Updated
Here’s Barney Ronay on the other two teams hoping to be No 1 at Christmas:
“While statistics and our mysterious friend Dr. Win Probability has Aston Villa as a clear favourite, I can’t help but agree it would be just typical if Sheffield United somehow won, perhaps because of a silly handball penalty decision,” writes Kari Tulinius.
“Living in Denmark, I’m following the game on BBC Radio Five,” says Tim Hall. “What a pleasure to hear Aaron Paul on the Friday Night Social.” So technically, I’m in competition with Jesse from Breaking Bad? No pressure, then.
John McGinn is an old school scurrier isn't he @niallmcveigh?
— Gary Naylor 85 (@garynaylor85) December 22, 2023
Is it a peculiarly Scottish thing? Gordon Strachan and John Robertson were similar in style.
And let’s not forget Archie Gemmill’s world-class scurry in ‘78.
“I’m at Hampden Park, Scotland’s national stadium, capacity 52,000, to watch visitors Dundee United take on Queen’s Park in the Scottish Championship,” writes Simon McMahon.
“It’s less than 5% full, mostly away fans. Queen’s have won the Scottish Cup 10 times, placing them behind only Celtic and Rangers, and are twice FA Cup runners-up. Maybe if there was a World Club Championship in the 1880’s they’d have played in that?”
Well Simon, as it happens, there was an unofficial “world championship” played between the Scottish and FA Cup winners, way back when. Queen’s Park won it four times and the first English champions were … Aston Villa!
Half time: Aston Villa 0-0 Sheffield United
Another attempted long ball to Watkins runs through to Foderingham, and that’s it for the first half. Diaby went closest in drawing a fine save from the visiting keeper, while Villa should have had a penalty for Souza’s early shirt-pull on Watkins. Sheffield United have come here to try and battle for a point, and they’re halfway there. More soon.
46 mins: It’s Sheffield United with more of the ball at the end of the half, and Larouci mishits his pass with Archer in space.
45 mins: Two added minutes. Villa would love a goal before half-time to break the tension.
44 mins: Chris Wilder will be happy with this first half – his team have been very defensive but it has worked so far, and Villa are starting to get frustrated.
42 mins: Digne attempts to unpick the massed visiting defence with a long ball, but it eludes Ramsey and Watkins, both in hot pursuit.
41 mins: Diaby then swings a cross in towards Watkins, who can’t get a toe on it as it sails through to Foderingham.
40 mins: Diaby, probably Villa’s brightest spark so far, finds Cash on the overlap, but the full-back rushes his cut-back to nobody in particular.
38 mins: The best opening of the half for the visitors, which isn’t saying much – but Bogle does well to cut the ball back under pressure, even if nobody in yellow can get to it first.
Updated
36 mins: “Are you sleeping?” Emery asks the referee, with a gesture to match. Then it’s Villa who get penalised, Lenglet leaning on Archer as Sheffield United try to break.
Updated
35 mins: Villa are taking on this challenge well, prepared to try and play intricate stuff in the penalty area. It almost works for Diaby, but his shot is charged down by Baldock.
Updated
34 mins: Diaby bolts down the left and breezes past Larouci – but can’t pick out a man with his cross. It rebounds to McGinn, who ignores the home fans’ pleas to shoot and tries to thread a pass to Watkins that is cleared away.
32 mins: McGinn is beginning to rove forward in his usual fashion, and a deflection almost presents him with a shot on goal on the right side of the area.
30 mins: Luiz has some choice words for Norwood – “second time”, he tells his opponent after another poor tackle in midfield. Souza then gets involved, jostling with Luiz and Diaby – even more than his nine outfield teammates, he looks like a walking yellow card.
28 mins: Larouci stops McGinn getting his cross in, at the expense of a corner. From it, a far-post knockdown lands to Watkins, whose shot flies over the bar! He had to adjust quickly, but that was a chance.
26 mins: Villa have racked up more than 200 passes; Sheffield United are on 15. The possession pendulum is at 82% in the hosts’ favour.
25 mins: Larouci nicks the ball from Bailey with the Villa wide man in dangerous territory. A chance for Sheffield United to break, but Slimane and Archer are both caught offside.
24 mins: Ollie Norwood is penalised for a late challenge on Douglas Luiz.
23 mins: Unai Emery has had a word with Taylor, unimpressed by the visitors’ hands-on approach.
21 mins: A terrific corner from McGinn finds Konsa at the back post – his flying header goes over the bar. Trusty was jostling with Konsa in the buildup – that non-penalty award means the visitors’ penalty-box antics are now under a microscope.
19 mins: There was another handball appeal from the home fans in the aftermath of that goal. The pattern of the game looks set, with United defending in numbers.
17 mins: Save! More than a half-chance here as Matty Cash sets Leon Bailey away down the right and he plays Moussa Diaby in. Diaby’s low shot, hit quickly, would catch a lot of keepers out but Foderingham gets low to parry it away!
16 mins: Another half-chance for Villa, but Foderingham is alert again to get off his line and gather the ball.
14 mins: Anthony Taylor pauses play to have a word with Vinícius Souza. The Sheffield United midfielder has been a bit over-exuberant so far, to say the least.
12 mins: From the corner, there are two further VAR checks – one for a pull on Konsa, the other for a close-range handball. John Brooks certainly earning his corn up at Stockley Park, but neither incident merits further intervention.
No penalty! We see enough replays to start to suspect a trip to the monitor is incoming – but then Taylor gets the nod to play on. Souza is a little fortunate there, it was a silly thing to do.
Updated
9 mins: Penalty? Watkins stretches for a far-post cross and goes down under pressure from three Sheffield United defenders. Taylor waves it away, but replays show a pretty clear push and shirt pull by Vinícius Souza …
Updated
8 mins: Ramsey holds the ball up in the corner and finds Douglas Luiz, whose attempted return pass into the area is just overhit.
6 mins: Yasser Larouci, stationed on the left of United’s back five, does well to hold off Moussa Diaby.
4 mins: John McGinn lifts the ball over the Sheffield United back line, but Foderingham is off his line to collect ahead of Watkins. A good job too, as the Villa striker was being played onside.
2 mins: Villa win a free kick close to the right-hand corner of the area, which Luiz backheels for Digne to bend a shot high and wide. A cross might have been the better option from there.
Manchester City are world champions, Júlian Álvarez scoring very early and very late to bookend a very comfortable win over Fluminense.
Peep!
Villa fans join in with a pre-game ‘mobile phone light show’, before Anthony Taylor gets us under way. Sheffield United are kicking off as 13-1 underdogs.
Updated
Hi-ho, Aston Villa! The ground is absolutely rocking as both teams take to the field. Sky have the hosts lined up in a 4-2-3-1, with McGinn and Luiz anchoring midfield. It looks like a back five for the visitors, who are in their tidy all-yellow away kit, with red and black trim.
Whatever your feelings on the festive period, the quantity of football can only be a good thing. Unless of course, you’re a professional footballer (I can’t imagine many are reading, but do get in touch). Here’s a guide to all the upcoming Premier League games …
As Matt Burtz points out, Villa have lost at home this season – to Everton in the Carabao Cup. “It would carry more weight if Everton hadn’t then lost on penalties to Fulham,” Matt sighs.
Over in Jeddah, Manchester City are closing on a world title but Rodri has gone down with an injury. The Club World Cup giveth, and taketh away. Join John Brewin for that one …
Unai Emery makes four changes from the team that won 2-1 at Brentford. Clément Lenglet, Lucas Digne, Douglas Luiz and Leon Bailey come in, with Diego Carlos and Álex Moreno dropping to the bench, Pau Torres injured and Boubacar Kamara suspended.
Digne and Douglas Luiz are both available again after suspension, as is Sheffield United’s Jack Robinson. Chris Wilder is still missing several injured players and brings in George Baldock, Ollie Norwood, Yasser Larouci and Anis Ben Slimane. Cameron Archer, who left Villa in the summer, will look to spoil his old club’s party.
Team news
Aston Villa (4-2-3-1): Martínez; Cash, Konsa, Lenglet, Digne; Douglas Luiz, McGinn; Bailey, Ramsey, Diaby; Watkins.
Subs: Diego Carlos, Álex Moreno, Chambers, Zaniolo, Durán, Dendoncker, Marschall, Iroegbunam, O’Reilly.
Sheffield United (5-3-2): Foderingham; Bogle, Baldock, Robinson, Trusty, Larouci; Ben Slimane, Norwood, Vinícius Souza; Brooks, Archer.
Subs: Adam Davies, Lowe, Fleck, Hamer, McBurnie, Traoré, Thomas, Osborn, McAtee.
Referee: Anthony Taylor (Cheshire).
Updated
Preamble
18 June 2020: the first Premier League match under ‘Project Restart’, following the Covid-19 shutdown. Aston Villa v Sheffield United at Villa Park, with one team chasing Europe and the other battling relegation. Back then, the roles were reversed and 19th-placed Villa clung on for a point after Hawk-Eye failed to spot that the home keeper, Orjan Nylund, had carried the ball over his own line. “I don’t know whether to laugh or cry,” said the Blades manager, Chris Wilder – and he didn’t know the half of it yet.
Villa went on to stay up by a single point as United fell away, finishing ninth and then slumping to relegation during the top flight’s silent era as Wilder departed. Returning after two seasons away, they have found it brutally tough and arrive here bottom of the table, with their former manager recalled on a rescue mission. A new Project Restart is in effect at Bramall Lane, but they can only dream that it might be as successful as the one launched at Villa Park 14 months ago.
When Steven Gerrard’s time finally ran out last October, Aston Villa were still looking down, not up, but have been transformed beyond all expectations by Unai Emery. They are third in the table and have won their last 15 home league games. Victory tonight would take them to the top – and with Arsenal visiting Anfield tomorrow, Manchester City still in Saudi Arabia and a reasonable run of games ahead, their title dream could move closer to reality in the coming weeks.
Having just seen off City and Arsenal at home, a team with two top-flight away wins since that fateful day in 2020 should pose Villa no problems. Of course, that won’t ease the nagging feeling that every fatalistic home fan will have. Wouldn’t it just be typical? Wilder and United may also feel they are owed something from that sliding-doors moment 1,282 days ago. Whether they can get it is another story. Kick-off is at 8pm, GMT.
Updated
