Air Force vs. Navy Week: A look at the Academies
Two Programs Heading in Opposite Directions
Contact/Follow @Sean or @MWCWire
It is officially Air Force versus Navy week! The first round in the three-team battle for the Commander-in-Chief’s Trophy kicks off this Saturday in Colorado Springs. One of the great traditions in all of sports, the Falcons once dominated this series and were stingy possessors of the coveted trophy, securing it 21 times. Compare that to Navy’s 16 and Army’s 10*, and you could be fooled into thinking all is well at the Springs.
Not so much.
Despite having an overwhelmingly better season win total than Navy and Army the last few years, the CiC has become elusive to the Falcons, who last won the series in 2022. By contrast, Army has won the CiC five out of the last seven years. To put that into perspective, they started playing this series in 1972, and the Black Knights have secured the trophy five* of their 10* times in the last seven years. Impressive or disgusting? It depends on which of the three camps you stand.
And if your curious about the asterisk (*) by Army’s win total, do a quick internet search using the terms “Army Football Suspended Honor Code”. Or you can click here.
“I can’t overstate the impact that Blake Horvath has had… He’s only gonna continue to get better.”
🗣️ @NavyFB head coach Brian Newberry breaks down the explosive start QB Blake Horvath has had this season ahead of Navy’s showdown w/ Air Force on CBS | @randycrossFB pic.twitter.com/8OD31ABLCC
— CBS Sports College Football 🏈 (@CBSSportsCFB) October 2, 2024
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
EXPERIENCE FUELS SUCCESS
The contrast between Navy and Air Force in 2024 has become blaring. Much of this is due in part because of the great progress Head Coach Brian Newberry and the Mids have made from last year. And if we’re being honest, there has to be a ton of credit given to their offensive coordinator, Drew Cronic. What he’s done with the development of the Mids offense under the controls of quarterback Blake Horvath is impressive to say the least.
Horvath is getting a ton of recognition this season, and rightfully so. He currently leads the American Athletic Conference in rushing and total touchdowns. If you have been following Navy for the past few years, basically since Malcolm Perry departed the program, then you know how desperate they have been for consistent quarterback play. As an Air Force fan, you have got to appreciate this challenge.
Horvath’s ascension and spectacular play should present a perfect case study for optimism among the Falcon faithful. The Navy quarterback was mired in a carousel of players rising and then falling down the depth chart in 2023. With the graduation of Tai Lavatai and Xavier Arline, Horvath entered this season with a clear path to take the reigns as the starter, despite a rocky 2023. And the investment has paid off. Take a look at the year over year progress from the Mids quarterback courtesy of Sports-Reference.
| PASSING | Season | G | Cmp | Att | Cmp% | Yds | TD | Int | Y/G | Rate |
| 2023 | 4 | 6 | 12 | 50 | 84 | 2 | 0 | 21 | 164 | |
| 2024 | 4 | 30 | 44 | 68.2 | 637 | 7 | 1 | 159 | 238 | |
| Career | 8 | 36 | 56 | 64.3 | 721 | 9 | 1 | 90.1 | 222 | |
| RUSHING | Season | G | Att | Yds | Y/A | TD | Y/G | |||
| 2023 | 4 | 37 | 183 | 4.9 | 0 | 45.8 | ||||
| 2024 | 4 | 47 | 450 | 9.6 | 8 | 113 | ||||
| Career | 8 | 84 | 633 | 7.5 | 8 | 79.1 | ||||
Now looking at the Air Force quarterback situation, the production is a stark contrast when comparing the two Juniors. John Busha has started all four games this season, and if we are being honest, the offense hasn’t exactly flourished. It’s worth noting these are his first career starts. But look at what Horvath’s production was in his first four starts, and it’s eerily similar. I am not saying Busha is poised to have the same type of breakout in production, definitely not. But what I am suggesting is, it takes time. And you cannot discount the reality of what an impact the pieces around the quarterback position makes.
Air Force is breaking in new pieces at every position around Busha. Not the least of which an entirely new offensive line. Navy took their lumps the past few years, but now have experience and skill surrounding their quarterback. Skill all over the field is a luxury that the Falcons have enjoyed for years, up until 2024. Now it’s their turn to take some lumps before molding the next core of Cadets to lead the program to another resurgence. But make no mistake, there are potential playmakers on this roster.
Air Force Football meets with local media to discuss Navy gamehttps://t.co/lBBZaK3Mdw
— Air Force Football (@AF_Football) October 1, 2024
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
SPOILED BY SUCCESS
When you think about the challenge that this season has become for Air Force, it should be a healthy reminder of just how good they have been for some time. Very few teams in the nation have won as many games year after year as the Falcons have in the past five seasons. Navy by comparison, had fallen on very hard times before the promise of 2024. Their four wins to date, match or exceed their season win total for four of the past six seasons. Air Force won 9 or more games in that same span, winning 11 twice and 10 another. That is the kind of success that is incredibly hard to sustain, and equally impressive. Unfortunately, it also makes hard times that much more difficult. But perspective is worth bearing in mind.
In case your wondering, success over that period of time has included a fantastic run against Power Five (now Power Four) programs. The Falcons suffered their first loss to a school in the P4 over that same span, this year. Take a look at how the Academies have fared against P4 and P5 over the same period.
The Academies vs. P4 and P5 since 2018 season.
Air Force 4-1
Army 0-11
Navy 1-5
Full disclosure, for Navy in particular, there are a lot of really difficult matchups in those five losses, nearly all coming at the hands of Notre Dame.
CLOSING THOUGHTS
I think what makes this season’s rocky start so much more challenging is the success that Army and Navy have had. The Falcons have been a winning machine, closing with Bowl victories like clockwork for the past few seasons, and it’s gone relatively unnoticed by the National media.
Army and Navy are 1/3 of the way through this season, and their promising start has made them the darlings of much of the same media that has ignored the shear dominance that Air Force has exhibited on a yearly basis.
This coaching staff and program have shown a knack for rebounding and doing so with a statement and staying power. Let’s see if Troy Calhoun and crew can accelerate that rebound, starting October 5th against their rivals from Annapolis.
