Pro-Palestine and pro-Israel activists faced off across the reflection pond on Melbourne University’s South Lawn on Thursday, in a tense, loud, large but mostly peaceful confrontation overseen by about 70 uniformed Victoria Police officers and a smaller cohort of campus security staff
The action began at lunchtime, when around 250 people including Alon Cassuto, CEO of the Zionist Federation of Australia, attended a “No Hate on Campus Rally”, organised at nearby University Square by the Australasian Union of Jewish Students.
From there about 60 pro-Israel protesters, wearing and waving Israeli and Australian flags, marched into the heart of the Parkville campus to confront pro-Palestine protesters. Some identified themselves as students from various universities, but most were much older than the usual student demographic.
Arriving at South Lawn, they were substantially outnumbered and out-sung by a wall of at least 300 pro-Palestine protesters guarding the “Gaza Solidarity Encampment” now entering its ninth day.
Campers and activists are occupying around 80 tents and gazebos, part of an encampment organised by “Unimelb for Palestine”. The group describes itself as a “non-affiliated, grassroots” group of students, alumni and staff who are refusing to leave until the university divests and discloses ties with weapons manufacturers and, in the protesters’ words, condemns “the genocide in Gaza”.
The Melbourne campaign is part of a wave of actions at various campuses around the world. These were triggered when administrators at New York’s Columbia University called in police to clear a pro-Palestine student encampment on April 18. Since then, more than 2,000 people have been arrested or detained on US campuses, The New York Times reported yesterday.
In Australia, encampments have also appeared at the University of Sydney, the University of Queensland, Monash University, Curtin University in Perth, and the Australian National University in Canberra.
Earlier this week, organisers on both sides — Unimelb for Palestine and the Australasian Union of Jewish Students — asked for outside community members to join them.
Among those who responded was YouTube personality, far-right provocateur and former Israeli Defence Forces soldier Avi Yemini, who proceeded from the “No Hate” rally to South Lawn with a bodyguard, filming and photographing.
Two pro-Palestine protesters approached Yemini who according to several witnesses placed his microphone close to their faces. Video seen by The Citizen shows a woman moving to brush it out of the way and the bodyguard appears to use his forearm to push her to the ground. This scuffle — the most visible confrontation of the afternoon — quickly de-escalated under a close police presence.
An executive member of the Melbourne University Jewish Students’ Society, which helped initiate the “No Hate” rally, told The Citizen that they were disappointed by the political co-opting of the rally by fringe elements, such as Yemini, which they said was “dehumanising” to both the campers and Jewish students.
“We don’t believe that such a hostile situation would have occurred had Avi Yemini not been there,” they said, requesting not to be named. “His disruptive … unwanted presence, turned a day that was supposed to be about unity into something that will now be clouded by his image and all the baggage his supposed ‘support’ comes with.”
It was difficult to hear much of what protesters on either side were saying. But shouts of “From the River to the Sea” and “Palestine will be free!” provoked pro-Israel protesters, who yelled “There is no Palestine”, “Go back to Gaza”, and “get Hamas off campus”.
The pro-Palestine crowd had the clear weight of numbers and loudspeakers, leading chants, playing music and performing dabke, a traditional Palestinian dance. A group of high school students, wandering through the campus, slid past protesters and joined in.
Dana Al-shaer, an organiser for Unimelb for Palestine, told The Citizen that her group “[maintained] their cool despite the ongoing verbal harassment and intimidation”.
“We have a no engagement policy with agitators and we successfully implemented that in today’s rally,” Al-shaer said.
Responding to a series of written questions, including whether the University of Melbourne had asked police to come to campus, a spokesperson said the “No Hate” rally at University Square occurred on public land. “Following this gathering, some participants came onto the Parkville campus, accompanied by the police,” the spokesperson said. “The activity on campus concluded peacefully.”
Al-shaer said she was worried about agitators attacking the encampment at night, following an incident at Monash University early on Thursday morning.
A video posted to social media showed a group of protesters wearing Israeli and Australian flags entering Monash University to confront activists at the encampment.
Asked whether the University of Melbourne would allow the encampment to continue, a spokesperson referred back to an email sent to all staff on April 25 as the first tents appeared. Vice-chancellor Duncan Maskell, whose surprise resignation earlier this week caused the encampment to erupt into cheers, said that the university respected peaceful protests but would not tolerate behaviours that may breach its policies.
Those policies include the controversial International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s (IHRA) definition of antisemitism, which the university adopted in January 2023 (one of only a handful to do so).
Last year, more than 100 Israeli and other civil society groups warned the United Nations that the IHRA code had “often been used to wrongly label criticism of Israel as antisemitic and thus chill and sometimes suppress, non-violent protest, activism and speech critical of Israel and/or Zionism”.
In speeches and banners, protesters at the University of Melbourne have described Israel as “racist” and a “terrorist” state, raising the question of whether these might constitute a breach of the code.
Asked whether it would apply the IHRA code in assessing or responding to statements and chants at campus rallies, the university did not provide a direct answer. In a statement it said it “deplores and actively stands against all forms of racism, including antisemitism and Islamophobia”.
“The way that the IHRA definition has been used is precisely to categorise statements like that as antisemitic when they in fact are not,” said Dr Max Kaiser, a historian and expert on antisemitism. He is also an executive officer of the Jewish Council of Australia, a progressive Jewish organisation formed after October 7.
“For any reasonable person, you can see that those sort of statements, some people might find them offensive or uncomfortable … but they don’t really reach a threshold where they are antisemitic or racist,” said Kaiser.
This story is co-published with The Citizen, a publication of the Centre for Advancing Journalism at the University of Melbourne.
Do you support the campus protesters? Let us know your thoughts by writing to letters@crikey.com.au. Please include your full name to be considered for publication. We reserve the right to edit for length and clarity.
